StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gays In The Military - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Should the military service, the last bastion of the heterosexual masculinity and pride be specifically impervious to any likelihood of gays serving in the armed forces? The paper "Gays In The Military" discusses this question and invites relevant pros and cons…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Gays In The Military
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gays In The Military"

Gays in the Military of the of the Concerned February 16, 2009 Gays in the Military Since times immemorial, the military services have been a cherished domain of the heterosexual males. The traditional attributes of military service like courage, continence, pride and integrity, no doubt stand to be so synonymous with the straight masculinity that the words gay and military do not seem to go well together. In the general American perception, the scope for inculcation of gays in the military service gives way to many doubts and apprehensions. The very word gay surely tends to open the possibility of unrestrained incontinence and corruption into the military service. Should the military service, the last bastion of the heterosexual masculinity and pride be specifically impervious to any likelihood of gays serving in the armed forces? The proposal invites relevant pros and cons. The contemporary trend towards liberalism and scientific rationalism has made the things both simple and complex at the same time. With the onslaught of AIDS, Hepatitis C and other such deathly maladies, any possibility of gays serving in the army has got enveloped in even darker and debilitating ramifications. This has even further bolstered the resistance to the entrance of gays in the military service. Infact the issue is fraught with serious and genuine medical, psychological, legal, human and institutional risks (Wolinsky and Sherrill, 2004, p.4). The traditional reluctance of the military towards allowing gays to serve in it is based on the time tested and deeply emotive biblical values that delineate the role of men and women in the society. However, the much criticized ban that prohibited the entrance of gays in the military service, about 50 years ago, drew validity from the fact that at that time, homosexuality was recognized to be a psychological aberration and thus the military was right and logical in pursuing a policy of culling out gays from the ranks of interested applicants (Showver, 2005). Still, the most current reality is that in the 70s, both the American Psychological Association and the American Psychiatric Association deleted homosexuality from their list of recognized mental illnesses (Showver, 2005). Therefore, psychologically speaking, there does not seem to exist any reason as to why gays may not be allowed to serve in the military. The standard objections raised against gays serving in the military definitely invite validity and concern in a professional context. It is a known fact that in the military, the personnel are required to lodge and serve in close vicinity and it is considered normal to witness one’s mates undressed. Hence the gays, who may find their naked colleagues sexually attractive, may hamper and jeopardize the general efficiency and effectiveness of the straight soldiers, who definitely constitute a majority. Yet, this argument may sound sexist to some, for being based on the premise that gays are generally pervert, incontinent and are devoid of any psychological and sexual restraint. In such a scenario, it gets really problematic to decide upon which side is right. The supporters of gay rights hold that such objections amount to blatant discrimination and prejudice against gays and lesbians. On the one side, the need for discipline and efficiency in the military service certainly do not allow for any neo-liberal experimentation, but on the other side, any possibility of inbuilt prejudices and discrimination in the exalted military ethics and conduct may deprive it of worthy and talented soldiers, who may be gay (The Record, 1993, p.1). In an idealistic context, an all inclusive and a broad based progress of the society may qualify a staunch rebuttal of so called homophobic arguments and reasons (The Record, 1993, p.1). Yet, it is also a fact that the survival of the American society and way of life depends on the quality and battle worthiness of its soldiers that cannot be sacrificed at the altar of gay rights. Especially more so in the contemporary times, when the US army is under the scanner of many global terrorist organizations, who are desperately scouting for tracing any chinks in its armor. “Assuming that our military leaders are not ready to assume the role of chief nanny for the troops, it should be obvious that this issue has to be decided neither by economics, privacy or efficiency. Instead we must confront it on the basis of civil rights (Wall, 1993, p.2).” The proponents of civil rights argue that gays are often subjected to a more than average harassment and disciplinary action in the military. It is also true that time and again people come across media reports covering instances of violence and abuse against the gays serving in the military. Perhaps this may be true, perhaps the military may be following its standard procedures that at least theoretically do not discriminate. Still, the basic fact is that the military is not supposed to be the fountainhead of civil rights, but the protector of civil rights. The society cannot and should not push the military to compensate for its unresolved issues. Gay rights is an issue that first needs to be resolved on a social and political platform. Giving in to the possibilities of compromising on the combat preparedness of the US army for just forwarding gay rights does not sound pragmatic and sane. It will be interesting to go through the statistics related to the issue. US census data published in 2004 revealed that the gays comprised more than three percent of the US military (United Press International, 2004, p.1). It also disclosed that there were nearly 36, 000 gays serving on active duty in the military, besides the 29,000 serving in the reserves (United Press International, 2004, p.1). Further, in the US there exist approximately one million homosexual men and women, who acknowledge to being veterans (United Press International, 2004, p.2). After knowing this, one may be tempted to construe that since so many gays have already served in and are serving in the military, perhaps it may be alright for the military to embrace gays without any scruples. Yet, it is also true that till date there exists no authentic study that has scientifically and psychologically analyzed the positive or negative impact of these gay soldiers on the combat worthiness and efficiency of the military over the years. The democracy in the US is about rights and obligations, about pluralism and assimilation. However, the survival of this democracy is dependent on a disciplined and professional military. Hence the inductance of gays in the military ought to be decided on the basis of sound facts and not emotional sways. Total Words: 1,097 References “Census Study: 65,000 Gays in Military”. United Press International. 2004. Retrieved Feb. 17, 2009 from http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P1- 101173236.html “Gays are not the Kryptonite of the Military”. The Record (Bergen County. NJ). 1993. Retrieved Feb 17, 2009 from http://www.highbeam.com/doc/ 1P1-22674102.html Showver, L. (2005). And the Flag was still there. Chapter I. Retrieved Feb. 16 , 2009, from http://users.sfo.com/~rathbone/gw400004.htm Wall, James M. “A matter of civil rights: gays and the military”. The Christian Century. The Christian Century Foundation. 1993. Retrieved Feb. 16, 2009 , from http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-13509999.html Wolinsky, M. and Sherrill, K. (2004). Gays and the Military. New York: Kindle. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Gays In The Military Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1551676-gays-in-the-military
(Gays In The Military Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1551676-gays-in-the-military.
“Gays In The Military Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1551676-gays-in-the-military.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gays In The Military

Arguing a position: Gays in the Military

Arguing a position: Gays In The Military Since a long time, the United States Government has prevented the sexually active gay members of its population from serving in the US Military Forces.... It can be inferred that sexual orientation of a gay person should not interfere with his ability to serve as a member in the military forces.... hellip; There are many authors and general people who feel that this form of prohibition is unfair and homosexual people including both gays and lesbians must be allowed to become members of the US military....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Number of Gays in the Military

The following paper entitled 'The Number of Gays In The Military' focuses on military life which is different from normal life.... Thus the number of Gays In The Military may go on increasing.... When we examine the Napoleonic wars, there also we can see the details about the presence of Gays In The Military.... While serving in the military, soldiers will never get complete freedom for leading their life just like the ordinary people....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Should Gays be Allowed to Serve in the Military

The United States is one of the countries… For the sake of this particular argument, the American challenges and the views fronted by various people become beneficial in analyzing whether gays should be allowed to serve in the military The “don't ask, don't tell, don't pursue policy is one the policies in the USA that cannot be overlooked in such a debate.... Ultimately careful evaluation of these considerations can result to the bearing taken in analyzing whether gays should serve in the military or not....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Homosexuals in the Military

The following paper "Homosexuals in the military" reveals a research regarding the rights of homosexual people in military services.... This same situation is the problem homosexuals experience while serving in the military.... military service is the example discussed here....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Homosexuality in the US Military

James Conway are staunchly opposed to” making any changes when the military is fighting large, protracted wars with its all-volunteer force.... (Newsweek Magazine) Military officials say that the service chiefs worry most about a “cultural backlash and displays of intolerance that would make the military look as if it had lost control of its troops.... This paper, Homosexuality in the US military, stresses that the Commandant of the U....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Dont Ask, Dont Tell Policy

n 1992, former president Bill Clinton, on his presidential campaign, promised to lift the ban on Gays In The Military which was then opposed by senior military officers and majority of the Americans.... This paper "DADT Policy " aims to justify and support the move to repeal the DADT as it is an unfair policy for gays and lesbians who are in the military service.... nbsp;One such policy is the “Don't ask, don't tell” (DADT), though on pending repeal, continues to be the current official stance of the United States regarding homosexuals serving the military....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Disadvantages of Homosexuals Identifing Themselves in the US Military

Brian Jones, a retired Army Ranger, testified at the House Armed Services Committee to express his brute dissatisfaction with disclosed homosexuality in the military.... hellip; A synopsis conducted by the Family Research Council in regards to 1,643 reports of sexual assault in 4 branches of the military identified that 8.... Unless the military were to segregate homosexuals in this type of environment that relied on close male-to-male contact, which would impede certain Constitutional rights, there appears to be a tremendous risk to incentive and enthusiasm for heterosexual peers in this scenario....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell

As such, this paper aims to justify and support the move to repeal the DADT as it is an unfair policy for gays and lesbians who are in the military service.... One such policy is the “Don't ask, don't tell” (DADT), though on pending repeal, continues to be the current official stance of the United States regarding homosexuals serving the military.... Military service units including the Navy and Army developed a method to spot and exclude homosexual draftees from serving the military....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us