StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plastic Bag Ban - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Plastic Bag Ban" it is clear that the construction of the plastic bag ban ordinance should involve a critical analysis of the benefits of the ban relative to the potential consequences. It should take into account both the economic and environmental impacts of the proposed ban…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Plastic Bag Ban
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plastic Bag Ban"

Plastic Bag Ban The debate about the effectiveness of plastic bag bans to achieve desired goals has been ongoing over the years. Plastic bag bans aim to reduce the pollutant effects, which is attributable to their production and litter. The bans encourage the use of reusable shopping bags. However, they have a negative economic effect on the plastics industry, retailers, and consumers. The use of plastic bags has been popular since their emergence in the 1940s. Currently, their production is about 260 million tons of plastics every year. Recyclable high-density polyethylene bags used once are currently the most popular bags for retailers and consumer. They are referred to as Single‐Use Plastic Bags and are provided at checkout point for transporting purchased merchandise from the establishment to a secondary location. Plastic bags, however, convenient have a huge negative effect on the environment. They persist in the environment for as long as one thousand years given their resistant to biodegradation. The average time of use of single‐use plastic bags is about twenty minutes, and the remainder of the lifespan is spent as litter in the environment mainly piled up in landfills. The photodegradation of plastics also adds to the negative impact on the environment. It produces toxins, which upset the ecosystems. The production process of plastic involves the conversion of fossil fuels into polymers. This process generates greenhouse gasses that have a negative effect on the natural climate. The marine ecosystem has been greatly affected by plastic with reported marine animal deaths as a direct result of plastics. The undesirable effects of plastics, particularly single‐use plastic bags has led to the growing popularity of plastic bag bans worldwide. These bans take different designs depending on the target population (Villarreal and Baruch 6). They take into account the economic impact of the ban on retailers and consumers relative to the ban’s effectiveness to control the negative impact of plastics on the environment. Plastic bag bans take various forms. One form directly limits single‐use plastic bags. They charge the consumer a fee on alternative bag types if a plastic bag ban and fee ordinances are enforced. Plastic bag bans have an economic impact on retailers, consumers, cities and plastics manufacturing industry. Therefore, the expected result of the ban should be considered relative to the economic impact on these groups. Retailers currently offer plastic bags to their consumers free of charge and take up this cost. Plastic bag bans and an added fee on the paper bag ordinance may result in retailers opting for paper bags, which may be of greater cost. Retaining the fees from paper bags will offset the purchasing cost. Retailers are also concerned about the loss of business to regions with no plastic bag bans. Current studies do not offer a substantial conclusion with some citing no sustained negative impact and the emergence of a new opportunity in the sale of reusable bags. A study by National Center for Policy Analysis cites negative economic impacts of the bans. The studies on the long-term economic effect for consumer and cities have also shown varied results. Advocates of plastic bag bans argue that restricting the use of plastic bags would reduce environmental litter and protect the marine ecosystems. Studies show that HDPE plastic bags represent about 0.6% of litter in the world. They, therefore, represent only a minuscule proportion of the litter worldwide. Thus, this implies that plastic bag bans will only address an insignificant portion of the problem. Studies in San Francisco after the implementation of the ban on HDPE plastic bags in 2007 showed that the amount of litter did not decline. The audit showed that the amount of plastic litter increased. The plastic bags that clog storm drains have also been shown to account for only 1% of the total litter in storm drains. Plastic bottles and other plastic items represented the higher percentage of the total litter clogging the storm drains. Bans on plastic bags, therefore, have a limited impact on the effect of litter on storm drains. Plastic bag bans also aim to reduce the impact of plastic on marine ecosystems. Claims suggest that plastic litter finds its way into the oceans causing the death of marine life and birds. However, concrete evidence to support this claims does not exist. Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration point out that little is known about the composition of the ocean floor and the so-called garbage patch forming in the middle is an unproven hypothesis. However, the flotsam has been shown to increase in the recent years because of the rise in plastic use. The claim that plastic bag litter is a significant threat to marine life is not substantial. Discarded or abandoned fishing gear, on the other hand, have a grave impact on marine life and should be addressed. The plastic bag bans aimed to reduce the impact of plastic on marine ecosystems should be reevaluated to assess the effectiveness relative to their expected economic impacts. Plastic bag bans and regulations aim to reduce the cost of waste disposal for municipals and to reduce the generation of waste. Plastic bags do not constitute a significant proportion of the total waste in municipalities. Regulations that restrict the use of plastic bags and encourage the reuse of used paper bags would likely result in increased mass of waste product produced (Williams 508). This is because NWPP, LDPE, and paper are significantly heavier than the conventional HDPE plastic bags used by consumers. The use of NWPP, LDPE and paper utilize significantly more water and energy as compared to HDPE plastic bags. This, therefore, implies that the general cost of waste management, water and energy use should be reasonably evaluated when implementing plastic bag bans to ensure that it is cost-effective in the end. Regulations and bans on HDPE plastic bags aim to reduce the total consumption of resources. By banning the use of plastic bags, they aim to reduce oil consumption. However, the impact may be minimal considering that a large percentage of plastic bags are produced from natural gas rather than production from oil. The consideration that some alternative of HDPE plastic bags particularly non-woven polypropylene is produced from oil should be taken into account when formulating legislations that ban the use of plastics. Studies show that exclusive use of HDPE plastic bags would reduce the total consumption of non-renewable energy resources, particularly coal, oil and natural gas, when compared to the other alternative bag. Water is another major resource utilized during the lifespan of the bags. It is used in production, during use and in the disposal. Studies show that HDPE plastic bags utilize less water when compared to the other alternative bag. The economic impact of resource use is an important variable in the construction of effective plastic bags bans and regulations. Greenhouse gas emissions are one of the concerns raised regarding the use of plastic bags. Bans and regulations on HDPE plastic bags aim to reduce emissions of greenhouse gasses at the production stage of plastic bags (Laurie, Starla, and Chris 372). The awareness of Global Warming because of anthropogenic activities has increased in the recent years and has become a chief concern for the human population (National Center for Policy Analysis 1). This has driven efforts to restore the environment and is one of the cited reasons for banning the use of plastic. This claim has, however, not been corroborated. The studies require taking into account several parameters for all bags used to produce conclusive evidence that reducing plastic bag use will lessen greenhouse gas emissions as opposed to focusing on the production stage only. The implementation of plastic bag bans may have unpredicted impacts. One impact that may not be straight forward is the impact on the health of consumers. In 2010, some consumers presented with a norovirus (Kimberly and Keene 1639).They were members of a soccer team from Oregon, who had consumed some food from a contaminated reusable bag. Reusable bags have also been associated with bacterial diseases and other pathogen related diseases (Summerbell 3). Proponents of plastic bag bans claim that the restrictions on HDPE plastic bags would reduce litter, protect the marine ecosystem, lessen the consumption of resources, and the emissions of greenhouse gasses. On the other hand, arguments against the plastic bag bans claim that they are discriminative against low‐income communities. The portion of waste composed of plastic bags is insignificant and hence does not justify the drastic action of plastic bag bans. Additionally, they would increase the use non-renewable energy resources, particularly oil, coal and natural gas. They also claim that they would increase the general water consumption with insignificant impact on the costs of municipal waste management. They argue that the ban would result in public health issues due to bacterial, viral and other pathogenic contamination of reusable bags. It is recommended that the construction of the plastic bag ban ordinance should involve a critical analysis of the benefits of the ban relative to the potential consequences. It should take into account both the economic and environmental impacts of the proposed ban. The implementation process should involve the education of the consumers and retailers about the ordinance, as well as any other necessary knowledge such as the cleaning of the reusable bags. Works Cited David, Williams, Charles, Gerba, Sherri Maxwell and Ryan, Sinclair, “Assessment of the potential for cross-contamination of food products by reusable shopping bags,” Food Protection Trends, 31.8 (2011): pp. 508–513. Web May 14, 2015. Laurie, Johnson, Starla, Yeh and Chris, Hope. “The social cost of carbon: implications for modernizing our electricity system,” Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 3.4 (2013): pp. 369-375. Web May 14, 2015. Kimberly, Repp and Keene, William. “A point source Norovirus outbreak caused by exposure to fomites,” Journal of Infectious Diseases, 205.11 (2012). pp. 1639–1641. Web May 14, 2015. National Center for Policy Analysis (NCPA). A Survey on the Economic Effects of Los Angeles County’s Plastic Bag Ban, Policy Report No. 340. August, 2012. Villarreal, Pamela and Baruch, Feigenbaum, “A Survey on the Economic Effects of Los Angeles County’s Plastic Bag Ban,” National Center for Policy Analysis, Policy Report No. 340, August 2012. Summerbell, Richard. “A Microbiological Study of Reusable Bags and ‘First or single-use’ Plastic Bags,” Environment and Plastics Industry Council, May 20, 2009. Table of content Introduction Economic Impact Plastic Bag Bans and Litter Plastic Bag Bans and Marine Ecosystems Plastic Bag Bans and Waste Disposal Plastic Bag Bans and Consumption of Resources Plastic Bag Bans and Greenhouse Gas Emissions Plastic Bag Bans and Other Unpredicted Impacts Conclusion and Recommendations Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Plastic Bag Ban Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Plastic Bag Ban Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1876982-plastic-bag-ban
(Plastic Bag Ban Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Plastic Bag Ban Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1876982-plastic-bag-ban.
“Plastic Bag Ban Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1876982-plastic-bag-ban.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plastic Bag Ban

New Business Proposal for ASOS

The product is to be similar to Anya Hindermarch's ‘I am not a plastic bag' concept that encouraged people not to use plastic bags (Winterman, 2007) with a number of customized touches added to it.... The bag would also have specific customer number ID on it which would allow bag tracking/identification.... The bag would be designed as such that it would ensure maximum protection of the clothes etc.... The bags would say, “Yes I shop at ASOS because I carry their delivery envelope shopping bag”....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Plastic Grocery Bags- a curse for ecological stability

Here is an excerpt of the news, “the Seattle City Council is considering a ban on plastic bags based on a ban approved this year in Bellingham” (Thompson).... Seattle again considering ban on plastic shopping bags.... om/2011/11/14/1905942/seattle-again-considering-ban.... The use of plastic grocery bags is harmful to the earth.... I take up the words of Vincent Cobb, who works for the destruction of plastic grocery bags....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Commodity Chain of a Reusable Grocery Bag

The traditional grocery bags are composed of plastics and are made from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) which requires tremendous amount… Reusable grocery bags can be made from several materials that includes biodegradable bags made from a starch-polyester (biopolymer) blend "Bags for life” made from low-density polyethylene (LDPE), heavier, more durable bags, The Commodity Chain of a Reusable Grocery bag One of the efforts of the grocery stores to improve our environment is to replace the traditional plastic bags with reusable grocery bags....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Dangers of Plastic Bags

Like the authors of this presentation I would like to reiterate the use of cloth instead of plastic and an outright ban of its use by the government.... Besides the obvious advantage of being particularly recyclable one individual utilizing one cloth bag can replace the use of 288 plastic bags in one year.... The paper 'The Dangers of plastic Bags' presents a plethora of dangers of the use of plastic bags.... This paper will emphasize three main arguments on the hazards of our continued use of plastic bags and recommend at least one advantage of reducing to the point of terminating our use....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Independente Movie Review

These two are most visible features of plastic pollution.... However, most issues resulting from plastic require learning and acquiring the essential… Besides, it is also important to learn the meaning of the extraordinary words and acronyms such as PVC, BPA, phthalates, and other similar complex words, which helps in further understanding the problem of pollution by Addicted to plastic (Independent Movie Review) The most evident pollution from plastic is from single-use bags, usually stuck on trees and Styrofoam cups that line up the gutters....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Usability of Rowenta Intensium Bag-Less Vacuum Cleaner

The paper “Usability of Rowenta Intensium bag-Less Vacuum Cleaner” evaluates an important home appliance for maintaining the hygiene of surfaces such as the floor and walls.... It is widely thought that bag-less vacuums were developed just the recently, the features have been in use since time immemorial.... nbsp;The previous vacuums, for example, used bag-less qualities until about three decades ago, when the feature was discarded....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Process into Practice: My Working Progress

In terms of material, I used particular materials such as an everyday object, cement, water, and the plastic bag, latex, fruit and here they act as properties in determining the form of my objects.... First, in terms concept whereby my works ideas come from my own childhood personal memory, secret, concealed....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

History of Industrial Design

By tracing the origin of plastics back in the 19th century, He highlights the different faces the plastic technology has assumed all the way from technological inventions to product… In an instance, the professor highlights the attitude changes after the world war in the 1960s.... e acknowledges the fact that the reputation of plastics had been severely damaged despite its pivotal place as a resource in History of Industrial Design by Jeffrey Meikle History of Industrial design by Jeffrey Meikle A perfect and splendid plastic history is presented by an American professor Jeffrey L....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us