StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay represents a case study on a particular situation which happened after a vacancy interview. Moreover, the writer of the paper will describe some general information regarding the ethical dilemmas and examine it in terms of the professional code of ethics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace"

 1. Situation: For the recruitment of information technology specialist, six candidates have successfully completed a pass / fail examination. All of them are equally qualified in terms of education and experience. However, before conducting an interview, I received a mail from you, directing the selection of George McDonough, a personal friend of yours and one of the candidates. 2. Ethical Dilemma: Ethical dilemmas are generally situations that violate or have a potential to violate the moral principles and behaviors which include: a. Value of Life – Human life has inviolable sacredness; b. Goodness or Rightness – Doing good, in addition to refraining from doing evil, is required so that the consequences are good for the individual and for society; c. Justice or Fairness – This principle relates to equality of treatment among the members of society; d. Truth-telling or Honesty – Although ethical action should be based on the truth, confidentiality (contact-keeping), related to honesty and individual freedom; e. Individual Freedom – Ethical decisions should consider the principle of self-determination; and f. Trustworthiness - Trust defined, is assured reliance on the character, ability, strength, and truth of a business. 3. Application of the Code of Business Conduct and Ethics: Following are the Ethical Standards as per the Organization’s Code of Business Conduct and Ethics applicable on the present situation: I) Conflicts of Interest: As your private interest may interfere in any way with the interests of the Company; II) Fair Dealing: This might affect our honesty and ethical behavior and we might not be able to act in good faith, with due care; and III) Honesty, Integrity and Objectivity: As this situation leads to conflict between honest and objective approach to recruitment and favor of any sort. 4. The Nature and Dimensions of the Dilemma: Following avenues were examined in order to ensure that the problem in all its various dimensions has been considered. This situation falls in the category of Ethical Dilemma as it violates the following ethical principals: c) Justice or Fairness – As it would be equal treatment of all the candidates; d) Truth-telling or Honesty – As by hiring the candidate of your choice my honesty would be impaired; and e) Individual Freedom – Further my objectivity and self determinacy would also be effected in this situation. Further this situation also has the potential to affect my moral behavior and this also constitutes ethical dilemma. Consultations with the ethics committee comprising of the HR personnel and supervisors, presented the following basic options: a) it would be violation of the general ethical principles as well as the Organization’s ‘Code of Business Conduct and Ethics’ to some extent as are discussed above, however, as all the candidates are of equal footings as yet and are equally compatible and capable as their results of the tests and the experience proves, we can also consider hiring Mr. McDonough. But for that effective interviews need to be conducted as these may result in certain other observations about the candidates too. I have also considered the ethical Theory that is suitable in the situation that we are facing now. The applicable theory is ‘Consequentialism’, which presents that the right action is one which produces the best consequences. 5. Potential courses of action: The following actions or rather decisions are open to me to consider: i) Carry on the interview proceedings of all the candidates, keeping in mind your request and considering Mr. McDonough above others. ii) Appoint Mr. McDonough without any further proceedings. iii) Conduct interview with no consideration or favors regarding appointment and appoint the most suitable candidate. 6. Potential Consequences of All Options and Course of Action. Considering the information that I have gathered and the priorities I have set, each option was evaluated and the potential consequences for all the parties involved were assessed. Following implications were observed: i) Carry on the interview proceedings of all the candidates, keeping in mind your request and considering Mr. McDonough above others: Gives a chance as to find out the capabilities of others too, and satisfies all the three parties, the potential candidates, you and me. It will not cause the doubts in the minds of the candidates as they will all be satisfied that they are being evaluated on their capabilities, appointment of Mr. McDonough will be as per your request, therefore, that will also satisfy your request and as all the regular proceedings will be carried and consideration can be paid to other candidates too if some extraordinary ability is discovered, this makes the HR personnel satisfied of their work. ii) Appoint Mr. McDonough without any further proceedings: If this course of action is adapted this tends to satisfy Mr. McDonough and you and will create questions as to the recruitment procedure of the company and will be against the Code of Conduct and Ethics. The company can be in the danger of negative promotion and publicity, as being one of the topnotch companies all we do is news, the candidates will be in the situation of disrupting the reputation, and this attitude and de-motivation will prevail in the company for a long time as prospective as well as existing employees will start doubting our ethics and objectivity on the whole. iii) Conduct interview with no consideration or favors regarding appointment and appoint the most suitable candidate: Tend to leave you unhappy and being the president you know better for the company then others. Candidates and the HR management will be satisfied, but that may lead to your unhappiness towards the selection, may also cause the appointed person if not as per your request to be the object of unnecessary critical examination and evaluation. 7. Evaluation of the selected course of action. Therefore as a result of proper analysis and discussion of the matter, I came to the conclusion that we will go for option # 1 that is ‘Carry on the interview proceedings of all the candidates, keeping in mind your request and considering Mr. McDonough above others’ because this is also the most suitable option as per the theory of ‘CONSEQUENTIALISM’ that is giving the most suitable consequences. By applying the test of justice, I assessed our own sense of fairness by determining whether we would treat others the same in this situation. Also the selected option does not seem to present new ethical issues. 8. Implementation of the course of action. Hence, it has been decided that interviews will be conducted from next week, we will consider all the candidates and as all of them are equally capable as yet (that is on the basis of the pass/fail exams and the experience) we will look into further details with additional benefits to Mr. McDonough. However, I would really like you to look into the matter if any candidate with exceptional qualities is identifies during the interview, so as to be sure that we are not losing any important future asset of the company. References: Aquinas, St. Thomas, Summa Theologiae, Thomas Gilby et al. (trans.), New York: McGraw-Hill, 1964–1975. Coady, C.A.J. 2008. Messy Morality: The Challenge of Politics, New York: Oxford University Press. Greenspan, Patricia S., 1983, “Moral Dilemmas and Guilt,” Philosophical Studies, 43: 117–125. –––, 1995, Practical Guilt: Moral Dilemmas, Emotions, and Social Norms, New York: Oxford University Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/culture/1421501-name-it-whatever-youd-like
(Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/culture/1421501-name-it-whatever-youd-like.
“Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/culture/1421501-name-it-whatever-youd-like.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Dilemma at the Workplace

Example of Ethical Dilemma

Brown (2011) states, “Ethical issues that arise in the workplace should be carefully examined, and handled with care, as the determinations of these ethical issues can lead to the growth or demise of a company”.... This ethical dilemma occurred in a company where one of my friends used to work as a customer service representative.... In the paper “ethical Dilemmas” the author provides an example of a company where a customer confidence problem occurred between an employee and a client of the company....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Ethical Dilemma in Virgin Group

This paper focuses on the ethical dilemma in today's business world.... It will further establish the relationship between company ethics and ethical dilemma.... ethical dilemma Business ethic is vital for any business entity to gain a competitive edge and attain its goals.... Causes of ethical dilemma In a perfect business environment, employees and employers would always do the right and perfect thing while conducting business....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Ethical Dilemma

ethical dilemma Name University ethical dilemma; Sexual Harassment at Workplace An ethical dilemma is defined as a complex situation that involves a mental conflict between two moral principals in which if a person obeys one it would transgress another.... When defining a business issue as an ethical dilemma it is essential to make distinction between personal and professional ethics and values.... “Absolute” or “pure” ethical dilemma occurs only when two (or more) ethical standards are applied to a situation but are in conflict with each other....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Workplace Ethical Dilemma: Pornography in the workplace

One fine day he called on her at the workplace itself.... In these cases, the women who are being harassed may focus their outrage on the pornography because they believe such protests will command attention; in the watchful eyes of human resource managers, feminist litigators, or conservative judges, the presence of pornography in the workplace stands out as a crude violation because of its sexual content....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Issue of Internet Usage and Employee Monitoring at the Workplace: Ethical Dilemmas

Though the internet at the workplace is meant for official purposes and communication, the staff to a reasonable extent can use it for personal purposes.... It is regarding the manner in which the internet is being used in the workplace by the employees.... The paper presents an ethical dilemma.... This is a huge ethical dilemma and needs to be resolved using sound ethical principles.... The ethical dilemma arising, in this case, is regarding the use of the office internet for personal purposes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Business Ethical Dilemma

The author of the essay "Business ethical dilemma" seeks to examine a workplace ethical dilemma and attempt to solve it.... To do this, the essay will start by describing a situation at my friend Mary's former placement workplace that posed an ethical dilemma.... ethical dilemma.... nbsp; Justification of the ethical dilemma.... Working for a few months at Sisto Mission Hospital as a content developer and data entry clerk, Mary came across some information that placed her in a dilemma ethically....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Ethical Dilemmas at Workplace

In the paper “Ethical Dilemmas at workplace” the author discusses the case of Mackenzie and Elena, sorority's president, who saw other sorority people talking in the hallway during lunch time.... Ethical dilemmas exist at workplace especially because most of them happen to our dear friends.... There exists a dilemma on whether this issue should be forwarded to the council or the matter should just be ignored.... Mackenzie is in a dilemma on whether to reject the whole recruitment process just because a few of the interviewee's ignored the basic rule....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Ethical Dilemma in a Business Operation

It often arises when a person has to choose between his duties and ethical practices (Stevens and Brownell, 2009).... Most of the times our practices are based… n ethical grounds, however there are certain situations where we need to choose between an action which is morally right and the one which defines our duty.... Following the Often times our myopic approach does not allow us to see the long term possibilities of an ethical action, thus we up taking the shortest and easiest way to fulfil our immediate needs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us