StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Latin American Identity - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Latin American Identity" presents a cultural, social and historical analysis based on Rodo’s Ariel and Retamar’s Caliban. Latin-American Identity is a complex and ambiguous concept, that often present dichotomies rather than unified wholes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Latin American Identity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Latin American Identity"

Latin American Identity: A Cultural, Social and Historical Analysis based on Rodo’s Ariel and Retamar’s Caliban Latin-American Identity is a complex and ambiguous concept, influenced as it is by numerous cultural, social and historical contexts that often present dichotomies rather than unified wholes. While Rodo and Retamar present different paths towards a Latin-American identity a great irony must be initially pointed out. This is the fact that, despite their differences, both writers use metaphors stemming from one of the great icon’s of European culture, namely William Shakespeare and his play The Tempest. However they may seek to reject European influence, the very metaphoric framework within which their argument grows is European in nature. Rodo and Retamar have contrasting visions of what will create a strong Latin-American Identity. For Rodo it is the educated intellectuals who must lead the way, while for Retamar it is the mestizos and the lower classes. Taking Rodo’s Ariel first, in this work the writer calls for a cosmopolitanism that involved changing/transforming European models of development and identity. According to Rodo, Latin-Americans should neither slavishly follow European standards/structures nor unthinkingly reject them. According to Rodo the sense of Ariel as ‘spirit’ can create a Latin-American cultural sovereignty: Shakespeare’s ethereal Ariel symbolizes the noble, soaring aspect of the human spirit. He represents the superiority of reason and feeling over the base impulses of irrationality. He is generous enthusiasm, elevated and unselfish motivation in all actions, spirituality in culture, vivacity and grace in intelligence.1 Rolo’s view of Ariel, and the manner in which it can inform an identity for Latin-Americans, seems based upon the Cartesian contrast between rationality and savagery, between elevation and baseness, between intelligence and ignorance. Essentially, all those features which are typically “European”, stemming mainly from the Enlightenment image of civilization are contrasted with those characteristics which were typically associated with the “natives” (i.e. non-Europeans, in this case Latin-Americans) who are perceived as savage. The colonial past, if not valorized, is at least presented in a softer light than many critics would suggest is both realistic and a moral imperative. As part of his vision of Ariel, Rodo does reject current North American cultural imperialism, but in this he almost echoes similar complaints from Europeans, especially the French. Current imperialism is rejected because it does not live up to the ideals of Ariel. It is coarse, unintelligent, appealing to the baser emotions and unrefined. It is, once again, a carbon-copy of the European stereotype regarding Latin-Americans. Rodo’s concentration on the educated elite as the best hope for creating a Latin-American identity raises the question whether such an elite, almost by definition educated in the European tradition, can really be seen as independent from it. Rodo argues that they can be: for Ariel is not a simplistic figure; he can combine apparently contradictory elements within a unified whole. Similarly, while the educated elite may appear European in their behavior and thought-patterns, they can bring to Latin America a new sense of identity based upon their intellectual confidence. According to Rodo, it is only those who have a refined mind who can adapt the intellectual, cultural, social and political dominance of the Europeans. Within the parable of the king that appears in Ariel, Rodo suggests that the leaders of society must cross from the world of action into the world of thought. This is, of course, the opposite process from what most political revolutionaries would suggest. Most use thought to spur action, but Rodo seeks for increased passivity: a slow evolution into the philosopher-king rather than the soldier/merchant-king. He describes this process thus: The ancients, in their wisdom, included my visitors within the family of otium, the wise use of leisure, which they held as the highest example of rational life - - - thought freed from any ignoble yoke . . . noble pleasure was the investment of time that they expressed as a superior mode of life opposed to commercial enterprise . . . the aristocratic ideal of repose. (p.47) (my emphasis) Rodo is quite direct in admitting that his vision involves an aristocratic ideal that assumed that a person can choose whether he wants to work or not. The choice of to work or not to work is moved to become a pleasantly philosophical dilemma; never mind that the vast majority of Latin-Americans must work in order to feed themselves. But the masses within Rodo’s vision are of little importance, because they are not the fulcrum around which a Latin-American identity will revolve. It is the educated elite who will create that identity, and if it trickles down to the masses, then so be it. If not, then that is of little import. Retamar presents a rather different view of Latin-American identity. He calls for, indeed, shouts for, a firm rejection of the European culture and values that he argues has belittled and emasculated Latin-American peoples for centuries. According to Retamar it is Caliban, the drunken monster who seeks to overthrow Prospero in Shakespeare’s play that should be the image of Latin-American identity. Caliban represents everything that Ariel is not: he is brutal, lower-class, loud, drunken and unapologetic. Compromise is not a word in his vocabulary. Retamar suggests that Caliban can be seen as a symbol for the Caribbean, and thus for Latin-America. Prospero taught Caliban how to speak, and now Caliban uses the language that has been taught him to rise up against his teacher/master. To Retamar this is a perfect image for how Latin-Americans should react to European culture. The idea of a complete rejection of everything European is impractical because it would be impossible and atemporal. However, the ideas and thought-processes, indeed, the very language that Europeans have taught Latin-Americans can be used to assert their independence from their former masters/teachers. It must be stated that Retamar was a Professor at the University of Havana (Cuba) when he wrote his famous essay, and so he was, more or less, forced to adopt a revolutionary aspect towards European culture. Thus he sees matters in terms of opposites: “America mestiza” versus “America europea”, “popular culture” verus “bourgeois culture”, “barbarism” versus “civilization” and ultimately, and most importantly to Retamar, “revolutionary culture” versus “counter-revolutionary/colonial culture.”2 It is ironic that he adopts the very European system of Cartesian opposites that he seeks to reject. Revolution in thought, apparently, is not as easy as Retamar suggests. But Retamar courageously defends his point of view, suggesting that European and Latin-American culture are so contradictory that a compromise which takes the best of both is impossible. Is it a case of either/or rather than both/and. Retamar intended his essay to be a tribute to Rodo on the centenary of his birth, and yet he presents a profoundly different version of Caliban from the man he is honoring. Rodo’s Caliban is a symbol of materialism and barbarism, whereas Retamar’s is a symbol of reaction against a kind of effete European culture than can only be countered through war, physical revolution. It is materialism that the two authors disagree upon most. For Rodo materialism will lead to a coarsening of the Latin American identity, while Retamar, steeped as he is within Marxist theory, rejects the idea that intellectual pursuits are more worthy than material goals. While they may agree on the rejection of the capitalist obsession with the accumulation of wealth, they disagree on the fact that all modes of physical production are somehow inferior to quiet introspection. To be succinct, Fidel Castro did not take Cuba from its previous rulers by quiet, gentle philosophizing, he took it at the end of a gun. He was Caliban-like, and that, within Retamar’s estimation, is a complimentary not a pejorative description. The fact that the working classes must rise up and take over culture within Retamar’s vision (a convenient concordance with what had happened in Cuba less than twenty years before) suggests essentially a rejection of intellectual discourse and the higher rationality that Rodo is calling for. Oddly, Retamar seems to suggest that intellectual exploration belongs exclusively to Europeans. In this manner he may be accidentally playing into the hands of those who would suggest that there is an innate superiority to European culture. While Rodo and Retamar disagree on much, they share a common vision in the idea that Latin-America should have an “identity” that is separate from those cultures that came together to create the sense of a unified region (if that exists) in the first place. It must be noted that the vast majority of the population of the region would have no idea what the writers were talking about with their esoteric arguments about identity, using fictional characters from a Elizabethan’s play as their models. Most of the population has little education, and must concentrate on where the next meal is coming from to feed their family. _________________________________________ Works Cited Retamar, Roberto “Caliban: Notes Towards a Discussion of Our America.” 1971. . Rodo, Jose. Ariel. University of Texas Press, Austin: 1988. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Latin American Identity Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Latin American Identity Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1703998-rodos-ariel-and-retamars-caliban
(Latin American Identity Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Latin American Identity Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1703998-rodos-ariel-and-retamars-caliban.
“Latin American Identity Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1703998-rodos-ariel-and-retamars-caliban.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Latin American Identity

Retamars Caliban

Roberto Fernandez Retamar, -a Cuban poet, essayist and the spokesman for the Castro revolution1-, asks himself the question: "Does a latin american culture exist" … In "Caliban: Notes Towards A Discussion Of Culture In Our America", Retamar attempts to answer this question by tracing back the process of identification throughout times marked by the Spanish colonialism and later the American (USA) neocolonialism. The author uses Shakespeare's The Tempest to represent Ariel and Caliban as the two opposite characters that have been used to identify Latin America....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Jose Enrique Rodo's Ariel

verall, Ariel is an essay about the struggle to find and preserve the Latin American Identity.... As Carlos Fuentes explains in the prologue, "Ariel appears as the emotional and intellectual response of latin american thought and latin american spirituality to growing North American imperial arrogance, gunboat diplomacy, and big stick policies.... This text basically deals with the question of how latin american culture is to survive in a modern mass society that often admires the United States democratic and utilitarian way of life....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Foreign Policy Makers in the USA

The initial group of Cuban self-exiles known as the "Golden Exiles" was responsible for establishing a prosperous and atypical exile community that would to this day exercise considerable influence overall early and subsequent latin american immigrants living in Miami.... While this does not allow them access to "white" society, the latin american immigrant community can show solidarity with other historically marginalized groups such as the African-American groups....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Afro-Argentines: The Reality Behind the Myth

Today, Argentina is termed as the “whitest” latin american country, with an approximately ninety-seven percent of so-called white or ethnically European population.... However, just how a country surrounded by others with such large Afro/black populations, and a country having… Latin America has a large population that comprises of people from African ancestry, yet Argentina, a latin american country, does For those of African ancestry, in particular those in Argentina, it is important to find out just why their history and perhaps their very existence have been so whitewashed....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

American Identity Paper

In Europe american identity Paper J.... The life in the British colonies of the North America had contributed a lot to the unique identity of the American people.... This imparts a kind of unity in diversity and North American colonies depict this unique identity.... It is their unique identity of concern for the fellow beings that offered them this unique identity which has made America what it is now.... John de Crevecoeur in his third letter ‘What is an american' reveals the true individuality of an american and makes out the differences of an american from European....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Anthropology of Latin America and the Caribbean weekly Reflection

In contrast with the United States, racism can be associated The nature of latin american society is made up of a variety of races and ethnicities that make most people have littlesense of racial identity.... (Sanabria Harry, 2007) On gender and sexuality, the latin american women for a long time have been considered inferior in allocation of labor activities and distribution of resources for economic growth.... Since colonialism, the latin american gender parity has reduced and enabled more women get education and training....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Latinos in Television

As the author puts it, race is a considerable facet of human life, as it stems from man's need to gain identity, and as such can be both positive and negative.... Latinos in TelevisionRace is a considerable facet of human life, as it stems from man's need to gain identity, and as such can be both positive and negative to any given person.... ichy Ricardo was a star character in the 1951 american hit sitcom, I love Lucy.... This can be seen by the fact that the highest paid TV actor is of latin origin, with numerous positive portrayals of Latinos in animated films and shows....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Struggle For Indigenous Rights In Latin America

Poor access to healthcareAccess to health facilities and services is a great challenge facing the indigenous people in latin american (Gracey and King 67).... Journal of latin american Anthropology.... latin America is a section of the Americas that comprise of countries where Romance languages are used as the means of passing information.... The paper " The Struggle For Indigenous Rights In latin America" discusses various challenges that affect the daily lives of indigenous people in latin America....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us