StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Respond to the online discussion about movie High Noon - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
12 February, 2011. Response to class fellows’ reviews: 1. You have rightly stated that Kant has emphasized upon good will for the existence of morality in an individual’s actions. According to Kant, an individual’s act is morally justified only if it complies with the individual’s duty and is done in good will…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Respond to the online discussion about movie High Noon
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Respond to the online discussion about movie High Noon"

12 February, Response to fellows’ reviews You have rightly d that Kant has emphasized upon good will for the existence of morality in an individual’s actions. According to Kant, an individual’s act is morally justified only if it complies with the individual’s duty and is done in good will. And individuals work out the most rational course of action through reasoning. I totally agree with you when you say that Helen and townspeople’s act of not supporting the town marshall and his wife lacked morality because there was no good will behind their selfish attitude.

However, you have jointly discussed the position of Helen and townspeople where you should have elaborated Helen’s role in detail since she did have good will within her intentions which the townspeople did not! By saying this, I am not supporting Helen in her decision of moving out of the town. I just want to say is that you should have clearly indicated that having good will is not enough to make an individual’s action morally justified unless it is accompanied with practical action. 2.

I agree with you when you rightly analyze the role of Kane as a moral activist fighting not for personal satisfaction, but for a moral cause. But you sound too confused about analyzing the role of Amy, particularly when you say, “Amy wanted Kane and this is what guided her, but at the end she dropped everything she believed in just so she can help Kane. Is this a selfish act or a dutiful act?” Kane was just as much husband to Amy when she decided not to stand by him when he was when she chose otherwise!

It is obvious that she felt good will and her action was driven by her motivation to help her husband out of the trouble as a dutiful wife. She was truly a moral activist. You did not at all discuss the role of Helen and townspeople as was the requirement of the question. Just saying “other characters” does not evaluate the role played by the townspeople and Helen against their supposed roles. You need to expand on their individualistic roles to make the response complete. 3. You have put forth a sensibly constructed argument that challenges the ethical justification of Kane’s act of thinking about the whole community and not his own wife.

However, I think it is not about his wife, it is about himself! He needed Amy as a wife for his own sake, and when he decided to compromise upon his personal sake for the sake of the whole community, he was indeed, dutiful to the maximum extent! Also, lack of discussion about Helen and townspeople’s role makes your response incomplete! 4. Your analysis of the role of Kane and Amy is perfectly right. You are confused about the role of townspeople. In reply to the question you have asked, I would say that townspeople were obviously selfish for telling a man to leave the town who wanted to stay not for his own sake, but theirs.

You did not say anything about Helen!

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Respond to the online discussion about movie High Noon Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1407903-respond-to-the-online-discussion-about-movie-high
(Respond to the Online Discussion about Movie High Noon Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1407903-respond-to-the-online-discussion-about-movie-high.
“Respond to the Online Discussion about Movie High Noon Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1407903-respond-to-the-online-discussion-about-movie-high.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Respond to the online discussion about movie High Noon

Conflicts on Film: Breaking Away and Antonias Line

They may involve deep-rooted moral or value differences, high-stakes distributional questions, or conflicts about who dominates whom.... In films like Peter Yates' Breaking Away (1979) and Marleen Gorris' Antonia's Line (1995), identifying the inner and outer conflicts of the main characters would help us in determining the movie's theme and its prime intention as an image of how the film's creators view their work as a whole.... However, all approaches have some tactics in common: talking about the issues, focusing on areas of agreement in the initial stages of discussion, negotiating concessions on each side and arranging for continuing dialogue....
9 Pages (2250 words) Movie Review

Film evaluaton about SALT movie by angelina jolie

This paper will shed more light upon the movie, important factors like graphics, sounds effects, the plot of the movie will be analyzed… Salt is an action movie and many people complained that it was hardly realistic but no action movie is realistic these days, some people were very disappointed after watching the movie because Angelina Jolie who works for the CIA hardly gets hurt in the movie and People who look for sense in movies should not watch this because it is senseless and highly unrealistic; the sound effects are really good....
3 Pages (750 words) Movie Review

The Corporation The Pathological Pursuit of Power and Profit

In the book previously written by Bakan, there is a high correlation between it and the film.... This is in consideration of the status and the position of the individual evaluating the behavior… The movie observes the world as the psychiatrist of the corporation, thus making a judgment on different issues.... The movie observes the world as the psychiatrist of the corporation, thus making a judgment on different issues.... The Corporation - Full movie, retrieved on 10th April, 2012....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review

Plot Summary about Oklahoma Movie

The paper presents Plot Summary about Oklahoma movie.... Despite the fact Laurey wants to show she does not care so much about Curly, she is in love with him.... The second pair, Ado Annie and Will Parker, too, get married at the end despite Ado were about to change her mind....
1 Pages (250 words) Movie Review

High Noon and The Unforgiven Movies

In the film high noon, the character Marshall of Haleyville was being acted by Will Kane.... In as much as he had good intentions, none of the town's people wanted to support him with his motive Movie Review high noon In the film high noon, the character Marshall of Haleyville was being acted by Will Kane....
1 Pages (250 words) Movie Review

Precious as a Movie About Child Abuse

The paper "Precious as a movie About Child Abuse" states that I would want to serve as a guidance counselor, making the healing process of children possible and free them from trauma and fear.... hellip; The movie reiterates the presence of social welfare.... The principal, Mrs Lichenstein, talks to her mom about Precious going to an alternative school Each One, Teach One, where, she thinks that Precious would get better learning.... She developed her writing abilities as their teacher constantly asked them to write about what is in their hearts....
9 Pages (2250 words) Movie Review

The Analysis of The Yacoubian Building

The movie, The Yacoubian Building features Adel Imam was directed by Marwan Hamad (Mattin).... The movie was set in a Cairo apartment building.... The movie's brevity is cemented in its theme when it does not shy away from controversial topics in the movie Review: The Yacoubian Building Egypt remains the long-standing capital in film production.... The movie, The Yacoubian Building features Adel Imam was directed by Marwan Hamad (Mattin)....
1 Pages (250 words) Movie Review

Hitch as a Comical Romantic Movie

This essay talks about Hitch which is a comical romantic movie that highlights the romantic survival wits in highly competitive New York romance.... hellip; The paper expounds on how Hitch employs the technique of nonverbal cues in communication between characters in the movie.... Imperatively, various comical effects relates with the use of non-verbal cues in romance and within the movie.... nbsp;The movie entails scenes where individual characters are trapped within romantic situations....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us