StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

History of Public and Community Health - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "History of Public and Community Health" discusses that national healthcare reform, acute care, ambulatory care, and public and community healthcare are all serious issues of political debate.  The nurse professional’s role within this setting should be to act as an effective advocate…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
History of Public and Community Health
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "History of Public and Community Health"

COMPARISON Public and community health—history There are similarities and differences between public and community health, but the similarities outweigh the differences. Generally, community health is seen to be a part of public health. Public health is more general, and is often attributed to the nation: community health is more specific, and is often attributed to a particular neighborhood or demographic area. The difference between public health and community health is basically semantic and based on scope: public health has a larger scope and reflects the healthcare needs, such as equity and accessibility, based on a wider range of the population than community health. However, what the two types of health and healthcare have in common, is an attention to the optimization of accessibility and equality, focusing on healthcare for all of the public, and all of the community, rather than just those who can afford it. In terms of the history of public and community health, public healthcare in the US started without any government involvement. It was basically run by religious organizations. Many hospitals maintain their religious roots today, in fact. After the Depression and the rise of social welfare, government support behind healthcare was increased and supported, and this created a support system. Then this social support system, a foundation of public health, was phased out more recently through the application of programs like managed care, Medicare and Medicaid being government, but with increasing business models and private involvement as well. Community healthcare today, based on this history, is often put in opposition to mainstream healthcare in America, because it focuses more on the client and less on the bottom line of profits. Public health, however, is often more mixed up with issues of managed care and government programs. “Grass roots initiatives contributed in part to the passage of Medicare, and they can work again. Ted Marmor says that “pressure groups that can prevail in quiet politics are far weaker in contexts of mass attention — as the AMA regretfully learned during the Medicare battle” (Dauner et al., 2005). Public healthcare today is a system that has drawbacks and advantages, depending on one’s perspective. Because it offers a wide variety of services in a cost-effective manner, many people support managed care as a balanced solution to healthcare which can potentially unite the agendas of community and public health. “Traditionally, health promotion and education efforts within the United States have been directed at the individual rather than communities and/or organizations. More recently, it has been recognized that health is tied to social and environmental conditions” (Dauner et al., 2005). These social and environmental conditions affect indivudals on the community level, in decreasing order from public health levels. “Community health promotion models typically combine community organization and citizen participation principles with behavioral theories to address ways to generate change at the individual and policy levels” (Altpeter et. al, 1998, p. 104). Different communication paradigms exist between the policy level and the individual level in making an effective community awareness program. “The social-ecological perspective of community health promotion emphasizes the need for coordinated interventions targeted at several levels of the community, ranging from individuals and their social networks to institutions and policymakers” (Altpeter et. al, 1998, p. 106). Within this system, derived from history, the nursing professional has various roles. Public and community health—role of the nurse There are various differences and similarities between public and community health, and the role of the nurse in these two settings must also be considered. Community and public healthcare have many advantages in that it seeks to support the whole of a society, whereas consumer health care is often about the bottom line and is dictated by supply and demand. Public and community healthcare put the bottom line at the quality of the care given to the patient, whereas the role of the nurse today is often in a system that makes free market negotiations more important than quality of care and access to all. The role of the nurse in public health is not to grant managed care organizations a right to all knowledge. Public and community health is about more than the healthcare organization delivering nothing more than is owed by the conditions of the contract with the plan. Consumer health care also brings benefits of increased technology, although community implementation is sometimes problematic. Accessibility is the key issue in the debate over public health. Managed care hopes to influence the rules of supply and demand in consumer care, and Medicare provide programs that increase accessibility for the poor and elderly. In the community healthcare plan, the nurse fulfills duties in two parts. “The first part is to serve as a resource and help create opportunities for people to share in community change efforts and the second part is to engage in the empowerment process as community partners” (Dauner et al., 2005). By uniting these parts as their duty, responsible nurses will be able to carry out their jobs as professionals, grounded in a secure knowledge about their skills and abilities. At the same time that the nurse is fulfilling this role as a public and community healthcare advocate, it must be remembered that “the social planning model complements the lay orientation of locality development by focusing on the problem-solving skills of the professional community, such as health care providers, to help meet the communitys service needs” (Altpeter et. al, 1998, p. 106). This brings the problem back down to the immediate level of caregiver-client interaction, which is where real change can happen in terms of the caregiver being able to recommend an approach for the population of clients and the clients being able to take this advice and reach a healthier outcome. Nationalized healthcare is an ideologically controversial issue that involves enormous financial and professional stakes for nurse professionals in the field today, and is something that relates to their foundational knowledge. The debate over control of the healthcare system today, in terms of possible conflicts of community and public healthcare models, also focuses on people in many ways. Many families are able to get adequate healthcare for their children, if they do not face significant disabilities or illnesses, but this does not mean that there is not a need for a comprehensive reform program that stresses the need for expanded healthcare coverage and health insurance coverage for the public, within a universal healthcare system such as those that exist in Canada and most other developed, industrialized nations (with the notable exception of the U.S.). Therefore, in terms of evidence and justification, it is often the case that, for people who think that extending health insurance coverage to the entire population of the nation is a moral necessity, including all of the public, and therefore all communities, in a universal plan requires no further justification. Additionally, nurse professionals in the field today must think of the innocent children who have no say in the choices made regarding their access or opportunity to receive quality healthcare. These children have no voice, but still in many cases they suffer unnecessarily. Acute care vs. public and community health In today’s healthcare environment, nurses in acute care positions are increasingly moving towards ambulatory care. But nevertheless, acute care can be compared to public and community health in many ways. First of all, acute care for the nurse is mainly a stationary affair, with the nurse operating within the hospital or clinic, or another healthcare setting. In community and public healthcare efforts, however, nurses are more likely to be involved in community outreach programs that bring them away from this stationary base. Within acute care, containing Medicare costs was a part of managed care’s original impetus. In the future, managed care will most likely expand as a system that is more efficient as time works out some of its current imperfections, if the measures are still being advocated in terms of foresight. Managed care provides healthcare services for individuals who are part of managed care organizations. It is a system that was set up to help contain costs, and the care that comes through managed care organizations is offered as a cost-friendly alternative to more expensive plans. HMOs or Health Maintenance Organizations are part of managed care also, and they provide quality healthcare for individuals on a cost basis that includes a flat fee. “We want to know far more than how strong public health groups are politically; we want to know what central political goods or purposes lie behind modern public health campaigns” (Dauner et al., 2005). In an acute care situation, Medicare HMOs which dropped many individuals from coverage to remain cost-effective, and others which have adopted a marketing stance that appeals primarily to healthy individuals and denies those that are unhealthy the option of managed care. The diversity present in Medicare HMOs also has meant that within many acute care situations, despite a general trend towards simplification, in some areas the services have created a large number of options that tend to encourage overlap instead of making the process of managed care more efficient. Statistically, “In March 2004, 56% percent of the RNs were working in hospitals, this is a decrease from 59% in March 2000… 29% of RNs were estimated to be employed in ambulatory care, community health, and public health settings, an increase from 24% in 2000” (Swan, 2007). This shows the changing demographics of community and public healthcare versus acute care settings. The only justification and evidence that is needed in many cases is a simple understanding of how equity should work in the theoretical construction of national interest, and the courage to apply principles of advocacy towards reaching a balance between the theoretical concept of equity and its actual practice in the U.S. No one knows if coming healthcare reforms are actually going to be meaningful, or whether there is just going to be another brief interest followed by no substantive follow-up. National healthcare reform, acute care, ambulatory care, and public and community healthcare are all serious issues of political debate. The nurse professional’s role within this setting should be to act as an effective advocate. REFERENCE Altpeter, Mary, Earp, Jo Anne, and Janice H. Schopler (2008). Promoting Breast Cancer Screening in Rural African-American Communities: The Science and Art of Community Health Promotion. Health and Social Work 23(2), pp. 104-115. Dauner, K, M Greany, and B Reininger (2005). Developing competencies in community health development. Academic Exchange Quarterly. Swan, M (2007). Transitioning from acute care to ambulatory care. Nursing Economics. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Comparison Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555485-comparison-paper
(Comparison Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Comparison Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555485-comparison-paper.
“Comparison Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555485-comparison-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF History of Public and Community Health

Community and Public Health

The disease control feature has been the greatest beneficiary of public funding throughout history.... nother feature of public health that has contributed a great deal to improving health status and quality of life through history is injury control.... This essay "Community and Public health" is about the historical contributions of the public health community and public health have several different features defining the different role they play in promoting people's health....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Marxism: Radical Socialism And The Communist Manifesto

His theory of the state and the materialist precept of history illustrated his radical idea of communism—a concept argued by many philosophers as a social utopia.... Karl Marx is a modern social philosopher and economist born in 1818 from the ancestry of Germany.... He is a historian and was a strong advocate of communism and wrote his philosophy which became the foundation of revolutionary movements led by Vladimer....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Ageing Population in Singapore as an Epidemiology

It is the work of public health professionals, therefore, to examine the factors affecting the health of communities and to come up with programs intended to protect community health .... The collaboration of communities, health professionals, and non-health sectors in promoting community health is essential in ensuring the continued success of public health.... Since then, a lot of other discoveries have been made in the field of epidemiology thus increasing the effectiveness of public health (ibid)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Marxism Is a Political-Economic Theory

This includes not only the working standards of the employees but a variety of other factors such as the standards of health which are determined by the bourgeoisie set to attain power.... hus, Marxists aim for a health system that will not deprive the poor of their rights to a justifiable and efficient system that will provide for their basic needs and wants.... Marxists view the health care system as a method for capitalist societies to search for profits while maintaining their capitalist domination and capital accumulation (Waitzkin 1983)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Old Public Health of the 19th Century

22 of his book that in the late 1700s, which is also known as an era of Industrial Revolution, there was no such concept as that of public health.... 'Most histories of public health begin with a discussion of what is known as the 'sanitation phase' in the mid-nineteenth century.... In the paper 'Old Public health of the 19th Century' the author discusses three basic public health movements, which are generally recognized.... The first is known as the Old Public health, and then comes the New Public health followed by the Ecological Public health....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

History of Community Nursing Matrix

larify the differences during each period with public health nursing and community health nursing.... dentify community health partnerships used during this period of time.... Essentials in community health Nursing Practice.... community health nursing: caring for the publics ... history of Community Nursing Matrix Affiliation: Complete the matrix with the following concepts, and relate the concepts to two different periods of time in history and the present time: ...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Public Health and Social Justice in the Age of Chadwick

Edwin Chadwick Revisited Christopher Hamlin, Public health and social justice in the age of Chadwick: Britain, 1800–1854, Cambridge history of Medicine series, Cambridge University Press, 1998.... This paper 'Public health and Social Justice in the Age of Chadwick' shows the importance of the first public health movement to protecting and promoting the health of people.... Public health practitioners believe that prevention is better than cure....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Comparing a Community and Public Health Nurse Verses a Hospice Nurse

community health nursing and hospice nursing are two types of nursing careers.... This research paper "Comparing a Community and Public health Nurse Verses a Hospice Nurse" highlights community or public health nursing and hospice nursing in detail.... The main objective of nursing is to use the knowledge of clinical judgment for providing care to people and to make them able in reducing their health problems.... Public health Nurse and Hospice Nurse are two types of nursing that have become popular in recent times....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us