StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The review in the paper "International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation" shows that the effects of trade liberalization on poverty in Africa cannot be generalized. It differs significantly between different nations and within nations themselves among different households…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation"

International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Introduction The role of international trade in alleviating poverty has been a topic of considerable interest among researchers for a long time. On the one hand, it is argued that trade liberalization leads to enhanced growth, which in turn will reduce poverty (Winters etal,2004 ).On the other hand, it is argued that trade liberalization can lead a country into less productive and dynamic sectors which can adversely affect growth and hence increase the poverty(Rodriguez and Rodrick,2001). However, theoretically it remains unsettled and remains an empirical question. The empirical studies show mixed results and show that this is a region specific question. In this essay, the case of Africa is discussed in this regard. Studies have shown that a stagnation of exports took place in Africa for the past three decades. Moreover, the reports show the composition of exports in Africa remaining unchanged with the share of Africa in the world trade remaining very little (Commission for Africa, 2005). According to the Commission for Africa (2005), given the high poverty, malnutrition etc in Africa without increasing the export performance of the African nations, it will be very difficult to obtain the goals of poverty reduction and enhanced export economic growth. UNCTAD (2008) shows the export performance in Africa far below the performance of many other developing nations. Hence, the review of some existing studies on Africa regarding international trade and poverty reduction in Africa is done in this regard. 2. Review of Literature Ng and Yeats (1996) showed that Sub Saharan Africa showed very poor performance in terms of global exports and the share of exports in world trade had been falling here since the 1950s. The authors argue the protectionist policies of the government here leading to the marginalization of the region from world trade and hence it remained non-competitive. The empirical analysis by the authors showed that the trade preferences of OECD provided a competitive advantage for Africa while the internal protectionist policies significantly contributed to the decline of the export performance here. The study hence demand for the need of more liberalized trade policies in this region which are needed to reduce poverty in Sub Saharan Africa. Anderson et al(2005) showed that trade liberalization can result in poverty reduction in Sub Saharan Africa through increasing farm employment and output, the real value of agricultural and food exports, the real returns to farm land and unskilled labour, and real net farm incomes. It also results in increased income growth, which is greater than for other developing nations and developed nations as shown by the authors in spite of some terms of trade losses. Hence, the authors demanded the need for more trade openness in the region as a policy measure to reduce poverty. Similarly Tuppy (2005) argued that in Sub Saharan Africa trade liberalization can produce welfare gains while this in turn will led to reduced poverty only of there are drastic changes in the economic and political circumstances like governance improvement ,removal of corruption etc along with the trade liberalization policies. This study however shows that trade openness can lead to increased competition and to reduce the protection of privileged groups, which have severe welfare implications. Hence, the author demanded the need for trade openness in Sub Saharan Africa as one policy measure to remove poverty along with other reforms. Collier (2007) in a discussion on the policies to reduce poverty in Africa demanded international trade as the most significant one for poverty reduction than international aid. The author demanded the need for trade openness in Africa so that the continent can compete with Asia through preferential market access and thereby reducing the resource scarcity in the region. All the above studies analyzed only the gains from trade liberalization and those too at the aggregate level. Sectoral and country specific differences are ignored here which can lead to misleading results. Moreover, none of these studies have distinguished between short run and long run effects of trade liberalization on poverty. Evans (2001) based on the example of Zambia, examined the trade liberalization effects on poverty at a disaggregated level. The study distinguished between different households based on income levels for the analysis. The results showed significant differences between the metropolitan and nonmetropolitan households regarding the poverty reducing effects of trade liberalization in Zambia. Moreover, significant differences were obtained for households with different income levels also in this study. Busse, and Groizardb(2003) obtained negative effects of trade openness on income levels in the growth regressions for Sub-Saharan African nations. However, the results are based on cross-country growth regressions, which ignore country specific effects. Moreover the analysis was static only and did not capture the dynamics of the phenomenon. Anderson (2004) obtained both benefits and risks through increased trade openness in Sub-Saharan Africa based on modelling. This study obtained favourable long run effects of trade openness in reducing poverty while considerable adjustments cost in this regard in the short run. The study also demanded several other domestic policy changes to be accompanied with trade openness to have poverty reducing effects in Sub Saharan African nations. Jansen (2006) examined both the gains and risks of regional and multilateral liberalization of financial services trade in African nations. The results showed significant gains from increased trade openness in terms of rising capital inflows and increased financial sector competition, which has welfare implications. At the same time, it can also lead to rising macroeconomic volatility, which can adversely affect growth. The study fond significant differences in terms of existing GATS commitments among the different African nations. Moreover, it also showed significant scope for more liberalization of banking services in all nations with respect to mode 3. Mabugu and Chitiga(2007) examined the short run and long run effects of trade liberalization on poverty based on a dynamic micro simulation computable general equilibrium approach. The results showed differences in short run and long run effects of trade liberalization on poverty. Negative effects in terms of poverty reduction and welfare by removing the tariffs on imports completely were obtained in this study while in long run the results are positive through accumulation effects .Moreover significant sectoral differences and differences among households like African, coloured and numbered households were also obtained in terms of effects of trade liberalization on poverty. Vos(2008) by examining the large number of studied on trade liberalization and poverty in general and Africa in particular obtained significant differences among different nations in terms of benefiting from trade openness. The study obtained most of the results sensitive to model specification and parameter assumptions. Hence, the results obtained in most of the studies are not robust according to the results obtained from this study. The impact of trade liberalization on poverty is mainly a country specific question, which depends on trade structures of each nation and hence cannot be generalized according to this study. 3. Conclusion The review in this essay shows that the effects of trade liberalization on poverty in Africa cannot be generalized. It differs significantly between different nations and within nations themselves among different households based on their income levels and locations. It also differs based on the trade structures of different nations. The review shows that trade openness alone cannot lead to poverty reduction but it needs to be accompanied with several economic and political reforms like alleviation of corruption and similar governance problems in Africa. Hence, a detailed empirical study is needed in this regard distinguishing between different nations, households and between short run and long run effects in Africa. References Anderson K(2008) “Agriculture, Trade Reform and Poverty Reduction: Implications for Sub-Saharan Africa”, Policy Issues in International Trade and Commodities Study Series No. 22, NewYork and Geneva, UNCTAD, United Nations. Busse, M., & Groizardb, J. L. (2003). “Does Africa Really Benefit from Trade?”. Hamburg Institute of International Economics (HWWA). Retrieved March 11, 2010 from http://www.ssrn.com Collier, P. (2007).”Poverty reduction in Africa”, Special Article, PNAS, vol. 104 , no. 43 p16763–16768 National Academy of Sciences, USA. Evans, D. (2001). Identifying Winners and Losers in Southern Africa from Global Trade Policy Reform: Integrating Findings from GTAP and Poverty Case Studies. Retrieved March 11, 2010 from https://www.gtap.agecon.purdue.edu/resources/download/344.pdf. Jansen M and Y Vennes(2006): “Liberalizing Financial Services Trade in Africa: Going Regional and Multilateral”, WTO Staff Working Paper ERSD-2006-03. Mabugu, R and C, M. Mabugu(2007): “Poverty and Inequality Impacts of Trade Policy Reforms in South Africa”, MPIA Working Paper No. 2007-19. Ng F and AYeats (1996) : “Open Economies Work Better! Did Africas Protectionist Policies Cause Its Marginalization in World Trade?” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 1636. Rodriguez, Francisco and Dani Rodrik. 2001. “Trade Policy and Economic Growth: A Sceptic’s Guide tothe Cross-National Evidence,” NBERMacroeconomics Annual 2000. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press, pp. 261–324. Tuppy ML(2005): “Trade Liberalization and Poverty Reduction in Sub-Saharan Africa”, Cato Institute Policy Analysis,No.557. UNCTAD(2008) : “Weak supply capacity limits Africas export performance: UNCTAD”, http://www.unmultimedia.org/radio/english/detail/35994.html, Accessed April 14 2010. Vos, Rob(2008): “Trade Liberalization and Poverty: What We Know and Dont Know” , DESA Working Paper Series No. 50 Winters A, Neil Mcculloh and A MxKay(2004): “Trade Liberalization and Poverty: The Evidence So Far”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. XLII (March 2004) pp. 72–115. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Term Paper”, n.d.)
International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Term Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1565282-international-trade-and-poverty-reduction-in-africa-anevaluation
(International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Term Paper)
International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1565282-international-trade-and-poverty-reduction-in-africa-anevaluation.
“International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1565282-international-trade-and-poverty-reduction-in-africa-anevaluation.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF International Trade and Poverty Reduction in Africa-An Evaluation

The Goal to Eliminate Economic Inequality

Unemployment is perceived as a basic cause of inequitable distribution of income in an economy resulting in some group of citizens facing poverty while others enjoying abundance.... Economic inequality results in poverty creating the divide between the rich and the poor.... poverty hinders economic growth and development.... That is mainly the reason for economists and government policymakers all over the world to establish ways on alleviating if not completely eliminating poverty....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Savings Rate in the African Countries

"To test whether or not Africa has built a critical mass of momentum towards sustained, poverty-reducing growth requires the use of multiple evaluation criteria.... Unfortunately, comprehensive, Africa-specific composite indices needed for this purpose are not available," Savings rate usually depends on capabilities, aspirations, functions and peculiar constraints of the region and might be helped with a policy evaluation by the Governments.... People's choices get highly curtailed with very few future opportunities, leaving generations to come in comparative poverty....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Urbanization in Saharan Africa

The hasty urbanization process in sub-Saharan Africa and the declining economic performance of nearly all African countries have shaped a new facade of poverty distinguished by an essential percentage of the population existing under the poverty contour in over jam-packed slums and sprawling shanty towns around the main cities.... international evaluations are impeded by the extensively conflicting definitions of urban areas adopted by national statistical offices, as well as great variation in the coverage, accuracy, and base years of national censuses....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Structural Adjustment Programs by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund

It has also contributed to poverty, unemployment due to reduced investments, and environmental degradation due to overemphasis on cash crop production among others (Holden, 1997).... Since the inception of structural adjustment programmes in the 1980s by the World Bank and the international Monetary Fund (IMF), many sectors of the economy have deteriorated especially agriculture in sub-Saharan Africa....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Annotated Bibliography for Africas Hunger

Although Africa experiences hunger, literatures have described poor farming practices, poverty, unfair trade markets, lack of proper measures by governments to introduce and implement food security projects among others (Lavy 132).... lthough Africa experiences hunger, literatures have described poor farming practices, poverty, unfair trade markets, lack of proper measures by governments to introduce and implement food security projects among others (Lavy 132)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Globalization and African Education

The purpose of the paper “Globalization and African Education” is to discuss the evaluation of the degree of globalization.... The evaluation of the facts presents a direct connection to alleviation of global poverty.... The evaluation of the degree of globalization forms the discussion content to this essay.... The evaluation of the facts presents a direct connection to the alleviation of global poverty.... The developing trade issue point to the changing trends in global status....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Trade Relationship between the UK and the International Communities

The mentioned exchange process is referred to as the international trade, which is regulated by trade policies (Suranovic 2012).... Second, international trade avails a wide variety of goods and services for the consumers.... Third, international trade improves a country's economic performance among other importance.... The paper seeks to present a critical evaluation of the appropriateness of the trade policies in the United Kingdom (Trade Policy 2015)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

An Empirical Evidence of SMEs in 20 Sub-Saharan Africa Countries

Sub-Saharan African countries reported with a highly sensitivity among economic growth, poverty alleviation, and SME growth rate.... Mainly, such firms are influencing economy of the countries by creating high prospect of jobs and reducing poverty level (Agbetsiafa, 2003)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us