StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control model and the due process model of justice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The major purpose of criminal justice system of the US is to enforce the law, uphold social order and to defend citizens from criminals as well as to provide them justice. Over the years, numerous laws have been passed and altered, but it appears that there will always be a…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control model and the due process model of justice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control model and the due process model of justice"

18 September Explain the difference between the crime control model and the due process model of justice.The major purpose of criminal justice system of the US is to enforce the law, uphold social order and to defend citizens from criminals as well as to provide them justice. Over the years, numerous laws have been passed and altered, but it appears that there will always be a debate on how society must punish those who break the law. Herbert Parker, a professor of law proposes two models to address the problem of crime: crime control model and due process model.

Crime Control Model places the main emphasis on rights and freedom of society to receive protection from crime and criminals. This model emphasizes efficiency and speed in the administration of criminal justice process. The advantages of reducing crime rates outweigh any possible costs to rights of the individual. Due Process Model accords priority on the right and freedom of human beings to be protected and sheltered from the power of the government. Values of this model seek to ensure that the state should prove a person’s guilt within a process designed to safeguard and protect personal liberties as itemized in the Bill of Rights.

Basically, the difference between these two derives from the fact that crime control model places emphasis on the prosecution of criminals, while the due process model focuses on restricting and limiting the scope of rules and laws by stressing more on personal freedoms and liberty. Besides, the crime control model pays attention on putting the criminal away, defending the innocent people. The due process, on the other hand, considers the rights of the accused person and rehabilitation. The courts incline more towards the due process model, which even supports the accused persons by securing their freedom and rights, to promise that every individual’s rights and freedom are protected as stated in the Bill of Rights.

Enforcement inclines in the direction of the model of crime control; they treat arrest as if they were already culpable; largely emphasizing on prosecution, arrest and conviction of those who have broken the law. The due process models needs to guarantee that every person is protected under 8th Amendment and the 4th Amendment, which allows no illegal and unlawful search and seizure. The rights should be put aside for the purpose of maintaining purpose of security and criminal justice manners.

On the other hand, sometimes one has to give up his or her right for the advantage of society as a whole. The justice system in US is a complex one and sometimes it becomes difficult to distinguish between the innocent people from the culprits. It also happens that many times the guilty has been freed and the innocent people put away imprisons because of the flowed system of imparting justice. Lastly, while the crime control model relies greatly on the police, the model of due process relies heavily on the courts and their function in upholding the legal actions of establishing guilt.

“The due process model is willing to accept that a person who is factually guilty will go free if the criminal justice system does not follow legally prescribed procedures in proving her or his culpability. Therefore, the due process model relies on formality in the criminal justice system” (Chapter 1 Criminal Justice Today, pg.19). Works CitedChapter 1 Criminal Justice Today. West Valley.edu. n.d. Web. 19 September 2012.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control Essay”, n.d.)
TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1602956-textbook-cj2012-fagin-explain-the-difference-between-the-crime-control-model-and-the-due-process-model-of-justice
(TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the Difference Between the Crime Control Essay)
TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the Difference Between the Crime Control Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1602956-textbook-cj2012-fagin-explain-the-difference-between-the-crime-control-model-and-the-due-process-model-of-justice.
“TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the Difference Between the Crime Control Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1602956-textbook-cj2012-fagin-explain-the-difference-between-the-crime-control-model-and-the-due-process-model-of-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF TEXTBOOK CJ2012 FAGIN-Explain the difference between the crime control model and the due process model of justice

Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma

Yet, in terms of the service of justice, the guilty drug dealer is convicted and taken off the streets.... In considering the ethical issues relevant to the ideas of honesty, justice, due process, and crime control, we are confronted by the radically divergent practicality of concepts that should be harmonious.... hellip; Honesty should always serve justice, and due process should never be allowed to be an opponent of crime control.... Similarly, the safety afforded the accused by due process can circumvent crime control and send the message that the punishment for criminal behavior is often escapable through manipulation of the system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Honesty versus Justice or Due Process versus Crime Control

This paper also explains the due process model.... The main purpose of the due process is to protect the rights of the accused and it provides a system of safeguard that will help in combating the abuse within the law enforcers and the crime control model which promotes the reduction and elimination of crimes by the agents of law and the police.... But recently, the concept of justice has been understood particularly when something is related to the legal system, like punishment of those who violated the law....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Current Justice Model and the Medical Model of Earlier Years Relative to Corrections

How to mitigate the most systematic suppression caused to the spirit and freedom of an individual from the day of capture, and in the course of his encounters with the police, administration and the slow-moving justice system?... Any method, any procedure, must aim to change the criminal thought process of a prisoner.... Harsh punishments can never usher in an era of a crime-free society; dedicated reformation and rehabilitation measures,...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Crime Control versus Due Process

The crime control model is considered conservative in nature while the due process model is more liberal (Perron).... Those believing that criminals should be treated as such and that there should be aggressive measure taken towards crime, are most often proponents of the crime control model, while those who feel people should not be beleaguered, that there are processes in place that should be followed and that law enforcement agencies are not the be all and end all of the criminal justice system are typically followers of the due process model....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Compare with crime control theory vs due process

In the said article, the author has further proposed the criminal justice model and the due process model.... The consequences of both the theories on the general public and the criminals have also been illustrated. the due process model In contrast to this the crime control model has been designed to make sure that the criminal cases are dealt fast and disposed off as early as possible.... When comparing the crime control and the due process, it can be seen that the proponents of both approaches uphold constitutional values....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Criminal Justice System Model

Differences between Italian Mafia and the Russian Mafia One distinct difference between the two groups is in their organization.... The author describes a criminal justice system model which comprises of three main sections, the Ministry of justice, the Crown Court, the Legal Services Commission, the National Offender Management service.... The rights of the accused are safeguarded throughout the criminal justice system.... On the other hand, the Russian Mafia is disorganized due to their fluidity and lack of adequate structures to control the group....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Models of Institutional Control

This paper discusses the three models (control model, Responsibility Model, and Consensual Model) and explains their effectiveness as forms of institutionalization.... nbsp;  control model Under this model, the prison administration has the authority in its hands.... A control model is an effective tool in sustaining internal order within a prison system (Stojkovic, 2004).... nbsp;… The model argues for a less restrictive prison environment and is liberal concerning policies governing prisoners' welfare....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Crime control and due process models

The first of Packer's models is the crime control model.... the crime control model is based on the legislature and it relies on it for criminal sanctions.... The prosecutors and the police are the law enforcers and authority according to the crime control model.... They are both known as the Packer models of criminal justice.... They were published as a means to help solve the complexities of the processes of criminal justice system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us