StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Modern International Law - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Modern International Law" discusses that where the question of foreign affairs arises, English courts or the judiciary traditionally consults with the executive in determining the legal status of the entity that is suing for the enforcement of a right. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Modern International Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Modern International Law"

Modern international law is based upon the principle of effectiveness, which implies that it is based upon actual situations which exist, while recognition on the other hand, is based upon subjective criteria. Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States 1933 defines the following four criteria, which are essential requirements to claim statehood:
(a) a permanent population
(b) a defined territory
(c) government; and
(d) capacity to enter into relations with other states.
The criterion of the permanent population would also include wandering nomads, while there is no requirement that the size of the population should adhere to any minimal figure; a population less than 10,000 would also qualify as a State. These are the four criteria that will determine whether a nation is a state or not and recognition is not one of the criteria that have been listed above to determine statehood.
The criterion (d) listed above that the states must have the capacity to enter into relations with other States, appears to imply that the State must be recognized by other States before it can exist as a political entity. But this is belied in Article 3 of the Montevideo Convention, which clearly states that “the political existence of the State is independent of recognition by the other States.” Article 6 further clarifies that “recognition is unconditional and irrevocable.” According to Crawford, statehood and recognition must be separated into two distinct categories, for example, Israel was not recognized by many of its neighboring Arab States, but it has existed as a State nevertheless. According to Cassese, it is effectiveness that is at the core of all legal relations and the Community of States has not thus far defined binding legitimate criteria for new States; on this basis recognition is not the relevant criterion that will determine statehood.
However, with the end of the Second World War and the development of the UN Charter, international law has been redefined. According to Article 4.1 of the UN Charter, membership in the United Nations is open to “all other peace-loving states” thereby implying that only a State will be recognized by the collective world body, i.e, the United Nations. Moreover, this article specifies certain conditions for membership; they must be (a) peace-loving (b) accept the obligations of the present Charter and (c) must be willing to carry out these obligations. These provisions imply that there is a degree of acceptance and recognition that must be accorded to a State by other States in the international community before it can be accepted as a State that can function in agreement with other States and have diplomatic relations with them.
Technically, recognition is not a necessary precondition for a State to come into being according to the four principles of statehood. But in actual practice, a State may need the support and recognition of the international community to function effectively, This was the case in South Rhodesia which was able to declare itself a state quite legitimately according to the four principles of Statehood mentioned earlier, however, the United National Security Council declared that Rhodesia was a “racist minority” regime as a result of which Rhodesia or the present day Zimbabwe became a State only in 1980 when it was formally recognized by the United Nations. Therefore recognition may not be a precondition for statehood but would be required to enable States to interact effectively with other states.
As the example of Rhodesia above illustrates, there are legal consequences of the act of recognition. Ian Smith’s regime, established in 1965 with a minority Government self-declared, was challenged in respect of its legal status because it was not by the rights of self-determination. On this basis, the minority Government was declared illegal under Security Council resolution 217, because it did not allow the people the right to self-determination and therefore had no legal basis. As opposed to this, Bosnia became a member of the United Nations on May 22, 1992, when it was accepted as a Member by the United Nations General Assembly. The criteria in this case for its acceptance as a State were the satisfaction of the right to self-determination, which was determined through a referendum. As a result, Bosnia was legally recognized as a State in the international community.
Within the UK as well, recognition has been a mandate for legal statehood. For example, in the case of City of Berne v Bank of England, a revolutionary group that was controlling the City of Berne was not allowed to file a legal suit to recover funds that belonged to previous administrators of the city because, being an unrecognized state, there was no legal personality existent under English law. Unless there is legal recognition, a State cannot sue or be sued.

Only recognized governments can have the locus standing to sue in English courts. In the case of Haile Selassie v Cable and Wireless Ltd, the granting of a de jure recognition to the King of Italy to sue in an English court deprived the Emperor of Ethiopia of the locus standing to sue, because unrecognized governments have no legal standing. Therefore recognition is vital from the perspective of domestic law as well. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Statehood Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Statehood Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1543277-see-attachment
(Statehood Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Statehood Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1543277-see-attachment.
“Statehood Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1543277-see-attachment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Modern International Law

History of Virginia Holocaust Museum

This essay "History of Virginia Holocaust Museum" focuses on the Virginia Holocaust Museum which is enriched with historical events and experiences seen through the eyes of a child it is an effort to create awareness among people to make them understand the story of courage.... ... ... ... People are witnesses to an interactive experience at the museum....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Human Rights Enter the International Politics

The paper "Human Rights Enter the international Politics" states that with the mandates and entities for the protection of human rights, bodies ensure international peace, yet much more is still needed to make the world a free place where only justice, equality, and liberty prevail.... So far, the United Nations has succeeded to a certain extent in ensuring that the war is not fought on an international level.... hat has changed about the character of international relations?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Customary International Law

Modern International Law, customary international law being part of it, gradually evolved as states gained status.... Denial S Papp1 states that Hugo Grotius is usually taken note of as the father of Modern International Law with references to his work, On the Law of War and Peace, published in 1662.... For this reason, international custom is considered a good a source of international law for the reason that if states take actions in a definite....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Analysis of International Law

As a result, the Modern International Law is a comprehensive legal system to structure society, wherein the legal rules are formulated based upon political.... As a result, Modern International Law can no longer be defined solely as the body of rules governing the relations between states.... This essay discusses the different theories of international law.... The essay analyses the philosophy of John Austin about international law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Principles of International Law

This paper 'Principles of international law' discusses the meaning, scope and significance of international law, the laws related to human rights and humanitarian law, and the general consequences of the breach of international law.... international law is a framework of rules which are established to govern the international legal relations among different countries across the globe and mediate in their economic, social, cultural or political issues concerning them (Bozcek, 2005)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Development of the International Law

The paper "Development of the international law" seeks to analyze the definition and the system of international law.... It also examines the structure of the United Nations, its contributions to the development of international law, and the importance of diplomatic immunity law.... international law is a set of rules among states that are established by a treaty or custom and nations recognize them as binding.... The modern definition of international law expands the traditional norms so as to include intergovernmental organizations and even individuals....
10 Pages (2500 words) Article

Various Types of Jurisdictions

Questions regarding the inauguration of law, validity, and value lie on the authority of the court (McVeigh & Dorsett, 2007).... Appellate courts have no powers to hold trials or hear evidence; however, they have the discretion to make decisions on matters regarding the law and issue formal written decisions and opinions.... Most states in the United States, have exclusive jurisdiction regarding their territory and have powers to make and enforce its domestic law through its local mechanisms (National Research Council, 2001)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

International Organizations and International Law

The paper "International Organizations and international law" tells us about international organization.... This paper seeks to discuss the role of international organizations in development and enforcement of international law.... Non-governmental organization (NGO) basically assists in the creation of international law due to their ability to mobilize public media and media support for their agenda items.... Intergovernmental organizations (IGOs) like the UN, the ICC, and the WTO serve as the primary multilateral treaty actors in international law....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us