StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Tax Avoidance - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Tax Avoidance" it is clear that tax avoidance is a legal activity but there is a need to discourage this practice. Courts cannot discourage it because it is impossible to devise a rule or a principle that can be applied to each and every case. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Tax Avoidance
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tax Avoidance"

 TaxationTax avoidance has been dealt with harshly by the courts. However, it is not something illegal and neither should it be. Therefore, the approach to tax avoidance should be reconsidered. To what extent can statutory interpretation be used in the battle against tax avoidance?Tax avoidance is a legal practice of manipulating the stipulations of the tax law to minimize one’s tax liability. It is different from tax evasion which is illegal manipulation of one’s affairs to escape tax.

Sometimes, it becomes very difficult to separate the two practices. The courts deal with tax avoidance very harshly because tax avoidance creates inequality between the groups which are capable of avoiding tax and the groups which are not. The “canon of equality” put forth by Adam Smith is not fulfilled.Courts have, however, struggled in coping with tax avoidance in just and equitable manner. Different judges have passed different judgments for different types of transactions and schemes.

They have developed an approach which has allowed them to disregard certain transactions which involve steps that have no commercial purpose. The problem is that certain statutes are not used for the purpose that these are enacted for. These are read in a different context and are interpreted differently. Courts have tried to be objective in such cases but they are of such a wide variety that it is almost impossible to provide justice.The Duke of Westminster case was a frequently cited case in the judgment of tax avoidance cases.

This case entitles the taxpayers to look to mitigate their tax liabilities according to their needs. The courts just used to look at the words and deeds of the individual transactions that formed a part of the scheme. This was changed by the development of Ramsay principle. This principle enabled the courts to look at the substance of the scheme as a whole. The courts now looked at each and every step of a tax avoidance scheme. This shifted the balance in the favor of taxation authority as more and more schemes were nullified by the application of the Ramsay principle.

However, it was soon discovered that the Ramsay principle was not applicable in each and every tax avoidance case. The funding in each case was provided differently and the sources of income were different in different cases. The Ramsay principle proved to be unable of having a general application due to its limited scope. In Westmoreland v MacNiven, it was proven that Ramsay principle was a method of interpreting only those statutes that referred to commercial terms but it had no application to legal or juristic terms.

Over the years, different judges have passed different judgments and different remarks about tax avoidance. Each case is different from the next and complications increase. Tax avoidance is a legal activity but there is a need to discourage this practice. Courts cannot discourage it because it is impossible to devise a rule or a principle that can be applied to each and every case. There are many ways of avoiding tax and each and every transaction that does that comes to the knowledge of taxation authorities after the financial period ends.

At that time, they can only take measures to avoid such practice in the future but the tax that has been successfully avoided remains uncollected. When the next Finance Act comes into force, the taxpayers look to find other ways to mitigating their tax liabilities. The HMRC has made the “promoters” of schemes to disclose specific information within five days of the scheme being implemented. This makes HMRC aware of what measures it should take to curtail tax avoidance. However, such measures also tend to make the taxation system complicated and the “Canon of Certainty” is breached as a result.

It is very important to alleviate the factors that encourage tax avoidance. A taxpayer looks to avoid tax when he thinks that the tax liability is too high or unreasonable. The taxation authority applies high rates to generate more revenue but as a result, it ends up losing a lot of revenue due to tax avoidance. When a certain group of taxpayers has to pay a lower rate of tax and another has to pay a higher rate of tax, the latter would surely look to avoid tax or take such measures which make it fall into the category of lower rate paying group.

Therefore, the basic problem is inequality of tax system. The Government always looks to alter the taxation system so that it fits to the fiscal needs of the country. Very often, it ends up creating an unequal tax system which causes resentment and encourages tax avoidance. The Government needs to employ such a tax system in which various income groups are treated equally and the tax rates are not unreasonably high. Otherwise, tax avoidance is likely to increase.ReferencesD. Ladds and M. Chowdry.

‘Section B: Issues in modern taxation’. Taxation Principles and Policy. University of London. pp 35-48.Freedman, J. ‘Defining taxpayer responsibility: in support of a general anti-avoidance principle’, [2004] BTR 332–357.IRC v Duke of Westminster [1936] AC 1. Lord Templeman. ‘Tax and the taxpayer’ [2001] LQR (October) 576.Westmoreland Investments v MacNiven [2001] STC 237. WT Ramsay v IRC [1981] All ER 865.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Taxation Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Taxation Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1448398-tax-avoidance-has-been-dealt-with-harshly-by-the
(Taxation Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Taxation Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1448398-tax-avoidance-has-been-dealt-with-harshly-by-the.
“Taxation Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1448398-tax-avoidance-has-been-dealt-with-harshly-by-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tax Avoidance

Tax avoidance,tax evasion,tax mitigiation

Tax Avoidance and Tax evasion are two of the most common terms and concepts used and utilized by the taxpayers in escaping from payment of taxes.... hellip; Tax Avoidance is a means to escape from taxation, which is allowed and sanctioned by law.... Tax Avoidance and Tax evasion are two of the most common terms and concepts used and utilized by the taxpayers in escaping from payment of taxes.... Tax Avoidance is a means to escape from taxation, which is allowed and sanctioned by law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Tax Avoidance by the use of Tax Haven Jurisidication: A Corporate Governance Issue

Tax Avoidance by the diversion of capital to tax havens therefore poses a significant difficulty for corporate governance initiatives at home.... The primary research question is: How does Tax Avoidance by the use of tax havens undermine the effectiveness of corporate governance?... The secondary research questions are: What is Tax Avoidance?... This research question calls attention to the distinction between Tax Avoidance and tax evasion....
12 Pages (3000 words) Dissertation

Tax avoidance and evasion schemes

The number of reported cases by the media with regard to Tax Avoidance and tax evasion has been very high.... For instance, a report from National Audit Office indicates that HRMC has a backlog of 41,000 cases including individuals and small businesses… Accounting Introduction The number of reported cases by the media with regard to Tax Avoidance and tax evasion has been very high.... Tax Avoidance is a legal way of minimizing tax liability, and it involves planning in advance an intended transaction so as to get a specific tax treatment....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

The Effect of Tax Avoidance on the Economy

The purpose of this paper is to report the concept of Tax Avoidance in business and discuss its impact on the economy.... The study of Tax Avoidance is important in the implementation of a couple of constitutional loopholes upon which taxpayers evade taxation for their own advantages.... hellip; The reasons for choosing Tax Avoidance as a study emanates from the urge to establish the various practices used in evading taxes.... Tax Avoidance Tax Avoidance is a subject concerned with the identification of the various legal loopholes surrounding taxation....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Global companies tax avoidance and CSR

Global Companies Tax Avoidance and CSR Introduction Corporate social responsibility or CSR is the term that came into existence during 1960s.... The discussion would be evaluating the evolution of CSR from risk management to Tax Avoidance tool, with respect to the IT, Internet, software and electronics industry, which would mainly drawing examples of those famous companies that has been criticised for their Tax Avoidance through CSR activities (Elkingtom, 1998)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Changing tax laws to reduce tax avoidance through the use of partnerships

However many governments… According to Feldstein (1999), this legality of Tax Avoidance could reach a point that it will turn out to be an illegality.... If any government were to seal or curb these Tax Avoidance Changing tax laws to reduce Tax Avoidance through the use of partnerships College Avoiding paying taxes is a scheme of actions used by individuals as well as companies to avoid paying taxes (Rice, 1953).... According to Feldstein (1999), this legality of Tax Avoidance could reach a point that it will turn out to be an illegality....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Tax Planning And Tax Avoidance

The paper "Tax Planning And Tax Avoidance" describes that effective and efficient use of tax-saving measures results in saving the tax payments of the organization and even individuals.... Use of the comparable system of IFRS across the broad would reduce the chances of measures taken by the company for Tax Avoidance to be overlooked.... Importantly, these tax savings have been legally benefitted such as grants, allowances.... hellip; An important rationale saving with planning is also a fact that it is the only portion of the benefit that the tax planner drives which remains the primary direction and guideline for the business....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Tax Avoidance - Debate Easily Resolved

(2012, May 1), Tax Avoidance is an approach where individuals use the legally provided tax policies to reduce the burden of taxation on them.... In addition, the UK law tries as much as possible to minimize the loopholes that individuals are likely to use in Tax Avoidance schemes.... It is in record that so many commentators have advocated for the formulation of legislations to counter Tax Avoidance in general.... Among many other things, Tax Avoidance has been viewed to as well be an ethical issue in business....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us