StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legitimate Authority - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses that while the author of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types of authority, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Legitimate Authority
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legitimate Authority"

While the of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types ity, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment. One of the problems with this article is that the author insists that choice is an important part of legitimate authority. He says that part of legitimate authority is voluntary compliance with commands, rather than people obeying commands for some other reason (172). The problem with this is that it leaves the subordinate in the superior-subordinate relationship to determine whether or not to obey a command.

For instance, everyone can agree that a teacher has the ability to assign students work and grade them on the said work. But, sometimes a teacher assigns work that a student considers inappropriate – the student believes that it is too hard or not to grade level, is too long and so on. Should the student have the right to challenge this assignment? And if the student challenges it, and the teacher insists upon their command, does the teacher have the right to force the student to finish the assignment, or punish them for not doing so by failing them?

In the practice of authority relationships in school, the answer is no, the student does not have the right to challenge a command, and yes, the teacher has the right to essentially coerce the student into following it through the threat of a failing grade. This does not mean that the system itself is wrong – the ability to fail students who do not behave or follow instructions is important to run a school or class room, but only that school systems fail to meet the requirement for legitimate authority functionally, meaning that other systems need to be in place to make authority legitimate in the way the author says.

This problem of choice also extends to other areas of the article. The author talks about principles and students and so on “accepting” the rules of schools, and entering an “agreement” with schools and other institutions (173). The words “accept” and “agreement” both work under mean the person, such as the student or the principle, has a choice whether they want to be part of the school or not, and that by choosing to do so they agree that all authority above them is legitimate.

But students are often forced without their choice by law to attend schools until a certain age, and the school they attend is decided by the where they live or what their parents tell them to do rather than their own choice. So legitimate authority, as the author talks about it involving choice, cannot function for the students; if they need to “accept” and “agree” for authority to be legitimate, as the author says, they should be able to say that none of the authority above them is legitimate, because they did not accept or agree to it.

This essay does not intend to say that the organization of teachers, administrators and so on are not legitimate forms of authority, but rather that choice to be part of an organization cannot be part of forming legitimate authority in school environments. This means that other structures have to stand to take their place, for instance the ability to appeal decisions a student or parent questions questions, because coercive forces work on subordinates in school relationships without them having a choice.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay
(Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay.
“Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1427721-critical-thinking-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legitimate Authority

Marx, Durkheim, and A dolls house

His theory on authority explains the various forms of authority that is possessed and exerted to wield power and control the three forms of authority are the traditional authority, charismatic authority and Legitimate Authority (Hamilton 147).... Finally, the Legitimate Authority is the authority that is derived from the laws or legislations.... Legitimate Authority is that form of bureaucratic authority that is applied in most institutions like school, armies, governments and other large institutions (Hamilton 168)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Violence among Nursing

Some of the recurring forms of abuse comprise of withholding information, belittling gestures, abuse of Legitimate Authority, silent treatment, and nonverbal innuendos.... Violence Among Nursing Name Institution Violence Among Nursing Violence among nursing has increased among healthcare professionals in United States....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Importance of Human Resource Management

Human Resource Management staff member or line manager enacting Human Recourse Management practices) is perceived as possessing personal capabilities and is willing to use them to aid goal achievement--separate from his or her influence based on position power and Legitimate Authority....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Law Relationships with the Concepts of Politics, State and Economy

Weber's attitudes to politics have been best described in his theory of Legitimate Authority.... The key concept in Weberian theory reveals the relationships between law and the state (authority).... This paper talks about the views of influential German sociologist Max Weber on the categorical concept of law, and its interactions with such concepts, as politics, economics and state....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Is a justified war ethical

The series of wars had the same background.... European Christians instigated the wars, and the conflicts were steeped in religious sentiment in that they were authorized by the Pope in order… The official aim of the Crusades was to defeat Muslim rulers and regain control over Jerusalem and other parts of the Christian Holy Land (‘Crusades,' Wikipedia....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Social Theorists

The Legitimate Authority has the ability to alter these decisions.... The theory is only acceptable if there are limits on what the Legitimate Authority can fairly order the individuals to do, a reason why it does not essentially replace all relevant decisions.... hellip; The social theorists are justified if the authority, in their sense is effective, or if it gets individuals to decide to base on the reasons it generates.... The distinction between legitimate and effective authority is that an effective one simply supports to change the decisions....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

International Politics Concepts, Theories and Issues

This research is being carried out to examine the concept that there is no Legitimate Authority in the international system.... hellip; This research will begin with the statement that researchers and students of international relations are always faced with questions regarding if there is any Legitimate Authority in the international system.... This paper takes the stand that the international system is anarchical in nature, and there is no Legitimate Authority....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Just War Theory in Christianity

According to the general concept proposed by both thinkers, the war can be justified by the following four factors: 1) The war should have a just cause; 2) The war can be started only by a lawful authority; 3) There must be a proportion between the aim of the war and its effects on human life and health, and 4) The war should be considered as a last resort to solve the problem....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us