StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Medical and Social Disability - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper, Medical and Social Disability, will discuss the history of disability, moving forward through the definitions of medical and social disability. How intellectual disabilities are seen in society today and finally what still needs to be done will be discussed…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Medical and Social Disability
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Medical and Social Disability"

Medical and Social Disability are treated much different today than they have been in the past. The approach is much more humanistic now than it was. There is also much controversy over what the definitions of each of these disabilities are and whether the need is even now being met correctly. There are certainly issues still remaining that neither the medical nor the social model have solved. Society still continues with problems relating to separation because of disability and we still continue to debate whether a disability is a disability after all. This paper will discuss the history of disability, moving forward through the definitions of medical and social disability. How intellectual disabilities are seen in society today and finally what still needs to be done will be discussed. History The history of all disabilities is dark. For many years a disability meant disgrace, guilt, and embarrassment. Many cultures associated any disability with sin and shame. That sin and shame often times extended to the whole family. Family members were locked away in closets or attics rather than allow the public to see them. This happened whether the disability was physical or mental. Many were cared for by family members, many were neglected and many were placed in asylums (Grob, 2003). Then came the mental hospitals. There essential function in the early years was to incarcerate rather than treat. Non productive individuals were removed from society and placed in these institutions as poorer families were not able to care for them at home. This included idiot children who could not be hidden away at home The Medical and Social Model Since the 1960’s, society has become more interested in how the mentally and physically disabled are treated. Two models have developed out of the concern, though there still remains much controversy as to what those models mean and whether society has chosen to do the right thing for the person or for society (Grob, 2003). The original medical model came about in the 19th century and believed that the problems causing the disability reside within the individual. The medical model of illness or disability is the result of a physical condition that affects activities of daily living. It is intrinsic to the individual and usually the individual’s quality of life is affected. This disability usually causes some clear disadvantages to this individual. The disability can range from loss of limb to shortness of breath from cardiac injury. The deciding factor in calling it a disability is whether it limits activities of daily living. Curing or managing in this case revolves around identifying the illness and understanding and learning to control and alter its course. The medical model is often cited by disability rights groups when evaluating costs and benefits of various interventions whether they are medical, surgical, social or occupational. This medical model is the one that most run up against when there is a decision to be made as to whether a disability will prevent work. There are fewer stigmas to the medical model than the social model and many would rather have been diagnosed with the medical model. Most treatment from the standpoint of the medical model is from control of an issue, many times with medication (Lewis, 2009). Last but not least the medical model assumes that a person cannot function at the level of others without special attention. There has been a shift away from the medical model which perceives disability as an individual problem to be cured or controlled towards a more social model (Humpage, 2007). The social model focuses on the relationship between people with disabilities and social environments and tries to locate the intervention that will work within the realm of social policies and institutional practices. This shifts us away from the medical profession as a whole and moves the person towards a vision of self-reliance (Humpage, 2007). The social model of disability proposes that systemic barriers or negative attitudes by society have excluded the person from factors in society. It recognizes that while some people have physical, sensory, intellectual, or psychological variations, which sometimes cause individuals to function in a limited or impaired way, they do not have to be disabled unless society makes them that way. There is not denial that some individual differences lead to individual limitations or impairment but rather that these are not the things that cause the exclusion (Lewis, 2009). The introduction of the social model was in an attempt to move the spotlight away from the medical model (Brittain, I., 2004). Some would ask whether it is cultural competency that is being considered disability. (Lewis, 2009). The UK organization, Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) claimed that disability was: “the disadvantage or restriction of activity caused by a contemporary social organization which takes little or no account of people who have physical impairments and thus excludes them from participation in the mainstream of social activities (Bayless, 2008). In 1983, the disabled academic Mike Oliver coined the phrase “social model of disability” in reference to these ideological developments (Bayless, 2008). The social model was then extended and developed by academics and activists in the UK and extended to include all disabled people, including those with learning disabilities, or have experienced the mental health system (Bayless, 2008). The Debate Rages There is tension between the competing camps. Disagreement occurs among the many studies on the different models and how they should be used. There is a platform for discussion and research in the fields of disability studies and special needs education. The last 30 years has brought about a wealth of literature in an attempt to consolidate the debate and produce consistent knowledge of impairment and disability. Part of that debate centers around the belief that many have which eludes to the fact that medical or social model perspectives cause the richness of experience of people with impairments is denied because of the two models (Simmons, 2008). This allows that the person becomes lost within the definitions or framework of the model itself because of medical symptoms or social inequalities. They believe that by moving past the models completely, there is the chance that a new knowledge of how disability works will emerge as a new model (Simmons, 2008). Perceptions of a disability by both the disabled person as well as society in general may be the place where the work needs to take place. A study by LoBianco et. al. (2007) discusses self perception and the disability and the belief that others perceive one of having a disability. This study showed that many disabled people do not know they are disabled until society tells them they are. Many feel that they have the same chances as anyone else, they just have to do things a little differently. Only after society begins to make amendments in everyday things like work do they begin to think they may be different (LoBianco, et.al, 2007) which then makes you wonder whether there should be a third model. Ralston and Ho (2008), would suggest that the terms disability, human being, and person carry with them great significance. This work states that there are ways in which we define humanity, personhood, and disability. We, in our definitions have decided that if the disability arises from a social reason then efforts are made to alter the social environment for that person. This may be impossible to do. We then question, because of our personhood and humanity, whether it is our moral obligation to the disabled person outweighs this impossibility. That brings us to ask, are all the impairments that we treat as disabilities really disabilities? Who should determine if this is an impairment and are we forcing the impairment on the individual? The end result of this according to Ralston et.al (2008) is that this is merely a squabble about semantics and rather than debate these issues, we should be moving on to how we can reshape the human experience. What happens Now Based on qualitative anthropological studies of American mothers of infants and young children with newly diagnosed disability, mothers understand and define disability in relation to the public. Mothers seem to comply with the medical model in order to manage opportunities in mainstream society. However, many of these mothers stated during their questionnaires that they would not have known that their child had a disability had they not been treated as if that were true (Landsmen, 2005). Today’s children have many issues including dyslexia, attention deficit disorder, birth defects and psychological issues. Are they treated differently than they used to be? Well, they are not locked up in asylums and in most cases they are not locked in the closet or the attic. However, many would debate as to whether they are not locked up in some manner. Deaf children learn to speak to other deaf children and are many times sent to special schools where they learn brail and sign (Roberts, 2009). Does this solve the problem of disability or does it create a second disability in separating them from society in general? Certainly this challenges the view that there is on medical model of disability imposed on the disabled and in particular disabled children. The presence of disability may be ambiguous in any given case. Parents need to advocate early over disability and how that disability needs to be treated or not treated (Ong-Dean, 2005). What about the child who has attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity syndrome? This child is hard to contain in the classroom and his ability to concentrate is affected. Most of these children are on some drug, of which there are many these days, which is some cases helps the child to concentrate and in some it does not. Whether these children are on medication or not, they are ostracized. First, they have behavior issues and second they are taking drugs. Are we making them better or worse? Are we taking away some ability they might have to control themselves by giving them medication instead? Certainly these are questions we need to be asking and it appears that might lead to a new model of disability. Persons with intellectual disabilities are still often treated like they have severe psychiatric disorders. Antispychotics are often used to treat their aggressive behaviors. It is interesting to note that acute psychotic disorder diagnosis has decreased greatly over the last few years but the use of antipsychotics are at the same level (Tsioceris, 2010). Other disorders such as genetic disorders, early victimization, and mood disorders are often treated like schizophrenia. It is not usual to find a child who is being treated for schizophrenia that has a learning disorder. These are the places where we are still failing. Children with learning disabilities, as well as adults are often shunned by society in such a way that it creates personality disorders on top of them. These children are often placed in classes for the learning disabled when the truth is, they just learn differently. These classes create a social conundrum for these children, however (Tsioceris, 2010). Adolescents with intellectual disabilities re likely to have emotional and behavioral problems. Studies show that many of them are in trouble with the law early in life. It is not difficult to understand why, considering the previous discussion but certainly tells us that we have a long way to go (Oesburg, Jansen, Groothoff, 2010). Conclusion Disability and its treatment have come a long way. There are no longer attics or asylums full of the disabled. Two models of disability have been in effect and have been debated and evaluated. Those being the medical and social models. However the model may still not be correct. How intellectually disabled are treated from the time they are young children may actually create bigger issues as they grow older. Adults find themselves separated from society because of disabilities of all kinds even though the present models were meant to help do away with that. Are the answers there yet? This writer believes no, much more research needs to be done and a better model developed Bibliography Bayless,P., Simmons, B, Blackmore, T. (2008). Postmodern synergistic knowledge creation: extending the boundaries of disability studies Disability and Society 23(7) 733-745. Brittain, I. (2004). Perceptions of Disability and their impact upon involvement in Sport for People with Disabilities at all Levels. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 28(4). 429-452. Grob, G. (2003). Mental Disability in Victorian England: THE Earlswood Asylum. Journal of Social History 36(4). 1108. Humpage, L. (2007). Models of Disability, Work, and Welfare in Australia. Social Policy and Administration 41(3). 215-331. Landsman, G. (2005). Mothers and Models of Disability. Journal o Medical Humanities. 26(2) 121-139. Lewis, A. (2009). Disability disparities: A beginning model. Disability and Rehabilitation. 31 (14). 1136-1143. LoBianco, A, Sheppard-Jones, K (2007). Perceptions of Disability as related to Medical and Social Factors. (2007). Journal of Applied Social Psychology 37(1). 1-13. Oesburg, B, Jansen, D,. Groothoff, J. Dynesora, G., Rerjneudd, S, Emotional and behavioral problems in adolescents with intellectual disability with and without chronic diseases. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research. 54(1). 81-89. Ong-Dean, C., Reconsidering the Social Location of the Medical Mode. An Examined of Disability in Parenting Literature. Journal of Medical Humanities. 36(2). 141-158. Ralston, C, Ho, J. (2008). Disability, Humanity and personhood: A survey of Moral Concepts. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 32(6) 619-633. Roberts, K. (2009). Lost in the system? Disabled refugees and asylum seeker in Britain. Disability and Society 15(6). 943-948. Rosen, RS. (2008). Descriptions of the American deaf Community. Disability and Society. 23(2). 129-40. Tsiouris, J, (2010). Pharmacotherapy for aggressive behavior in persons with intellectual disabilities: treatment or mistreatment? Journal of Intellectual Disability Research: 54(1) 1-16. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Medical and Social Disability Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words”, n.d.)
Medical and Social Disability Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1515235-medical-and-social-disability
(Medical and Social Disability Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Medical and Social Disability Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1515235-medical-and-social-disability.
“Medical and Social Disability Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1515235-medical-and-social-disability.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical and Social Disability

Living with Physical disability

Physical disability is defined as an “inability to engage in any substantial gainful activity by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental impairment which can be expected to last or has lasted for a continuous period of not less than 12 months” (The Free… A person who is physically disabled is not able to live a normal life like others around him and this adds to his frustration and hopelessness.... It is a tragedy of our society that disabled persons have to suffer from discrimination everywhere and have to undergo harsh Your full July 26, Physical disability Physical disability is defined as an “inability to engage in any substantial gainful activity by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental impairment which can be expected to last or has lasted for a continuous period of not less than 12 months” (The Free Dictionary)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Methods of Payment Analysis

To this end, the Investorpedia (2011) explains that the commercial healthcare insurance is “a type of health insurance that covers medical expenses and disability income for the insured.... For this reason, there are always reviews of the healthcare system to ensure that the people of the nation have what is expected when it comes to the provision of quality… One of the healthcare reviews have led to the introduction of the healthcare payment system....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Medical Model of Disability

The social theories are established to give a clear understanding of a given Currently, medical model of disability is used by many people use it to view disability.... It is propagated by the disabled people who feel that their disability is as a result of personal problem and would prefer to keep their disability, and avoid treatment.... This paper seeks to discuss the extent to which the social model itself can be viewed as outdated in reference to the shift in medical understanding of disability....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Medicare vs. Medicaid

These programs have increased the number of citizens seeking medical and health services, therefore, is predicted growth in employment in the health sector.... Medicare is the largest health insurance covering hospital and medical care for citizens at 65 years or older, some beneficiaries of the Social security disability and in some states it is expanded to citizens with permanent kidney failure.... art A, referred to as Hospital insurance, financed by the social security taxes....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Impact of Current Legislation on Social Model of Disability

This literature review "The Impact of Current Legislation on Social Model of disability" discusses the extent to which current legislation relating to disability supports the social model and how much it still reflects a medical model of understanding disability that is not necessarily inability.... hellip; disability is not necessarily inability; hence the outdated view of regarding physically challenged individuals as incapable of independent existence has been discarded....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Long-Term Viability of Medicaid and Medicare

Obama government in an endeavor to address the long-term viability of the Medicare and Medicaid had introduced the Affordable Health Care Act in 2010 with stiff opposition from Republicans and this research essay will attempt to ponder the strategies of the American government in providing a successful long-term medical benefits scheme to its citizens in detail.... Medicare is said to be responsible for cost inflation in health care mainly due to elderly employ their benefits to buy fee for service medical care instead of managed care....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Field of Disability and SEN - Polarisation over the Social and Medical Models

This study shall reflect upon both medical and social models.... The paper "Field of disability and SEN - Polarisation over the Social and Medical Models" argues social model is beneficial for many humans in giving them a respectful position in society.... nbsp;  … This study would be focused on SEN legislation and the field of disability.... There are human rights issues centered on disability.... iscussion A brief history of models The social model of disability was an extended version of the medical model of disability....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Notion of Disability as a Social Construct

he notion that disability is socially constructed can be derived from associating disability to a specific cultural and social context.... This essay "The Notion of disability as a Social Construct" focuses on defining disability that has been a complex issue for many years.... This is because various models have been formulated to try and provide a standardized meaning to the concept of disability.... The argument that disability is a socially constructed phenomenon can be backed by several factors....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us